Wisconsin Small Claims Replevin vs Money Judgment

Two Kinds of Judgment, Two Enforcement Paths

Wisconsin small claims court issues two fundamentally different types of judgment, and mixing up the enforcement procedures is one of the most common mistakes self-represented litigants make.

A money judgment orders the debtor to pay a specific dollar amount. Enforcement uses financial tools: wage garnishment, bank levies, property execution through the sheriff, and judgment liens on real estate.

A replevin order commands the return of specific personal property — a car, equipment, or other tangible goods. Enforcement is physical: the sheriff seizes the specific item and delivers it to you.

Money Judgment Enforcement

Most small claims judgments are money judgments. The enforcement toolkit includes:

• Financial disclosure (Form SC-506B) — the debtor must list all assets within 15 days
• Judgment docketing — creates a 10-year real estate lien ($5 fee)
• Earnings garnishment (Forms CV-421/CV-422) — withholds up to 20% of disposable wages for 13 weeks, subject to exemptions
• Non-earnings garnishment (Form SC-301) — freezes and levies bank accounts
• Execution against property — the sheriff seizes and sells non-exempt tangible property

The instruction guide for the entire money judgment collection process is Form SC-6090V, available on wicourts.gov.

Replevin Order Enforcement

Replevin actions under Wis. Stat. § 799.01(1)(b) target specific items. If the court orders the debtor to return your property and they refuse, enforcement requires:

1. Obtaining a Writ of Replevin from the Clerk of Circuit Court
2. Delivering the writ to the county sheriff
3. The sheriff physically seizes the property and delivers it to you

The instruction guide is Form SC-6100V. Unlike money judgments, you don't use garnishment or financial disclosure — those tools are for recovering dollars, not property.

When Replevin Converts to Money

If the sheriff can't find the property — it's been sold, destroyed, or hidden — the court can enter an alternative money judgment for the fair market value of the property under Wis. Stat. § 799.01(1)(b). At that point, enforcement shifts entirely to the money judgment toolkit.

This conversion happens more often than you'd expect. A debtor ordered to return a $3,000 piece of equipment may have already sold it. Once the court converts to a money judgment, you pursue the dollar amount through standard enforcement: financial disclosure, garnishment, liens, and execution.

Which One Do You Have?

Check your judgment entry on CCAP or the physical judgment document. A money judgment states a dollar amount the debtor must pay. A replevin order describes specific property the debtor must return. Some cases result in both — a replevin order for the property plus a money judgment for associated damages.

If you have a money judgment and you're unsure where to start, the Wisconsin judgment collection guide walks through the full enforcement sequence from financial disclosure to satisfaction of judgment, with the forms and fees for each step.

See more Wisconsin guides →