Virginia Warrant in Detinue Form DC-404 Explained

Detinue vs. Debt: Two Different Claims

Most small claims defendants in Virginia receive a Warrant in Debt (Form DC-402) — a money claim. But if someone is suing you to get a specific piece of personal property back, you'll receive a Warrant in Detinue (Form DC-404) instead. This is the Small Claims Division's form for property recovery actions.

A detinue action means the plaintiff isn't asking for money (or not primarily). They want the item itself returned. Common scenarios: a landlord suing to recover equipment left on the property, a lender trying to recover collateral, a family member demanding return of a vehicle titled in their name, or a former business partner seeking the return of shared tools or inventory.

The property's value must fall within the $5,000 jurisdictional cap under Va. Code § 16.1-122.2. If the disputed property is worth more, the case belongs on the regular General District Court civil docket (up to $50,000) or in Circuit Court.

What Form DC-404 Looks Like

Form DC-404 follows the same two-sided layout as the more common DC-402, but the claim section describes specific personal property rather than a dollar amount owed. The front of the form identifies:

• The court and case number
• The plaintiff and defendant names and addresses
• A description of the property the plaintiff wants returned
• The claimed value of the property
• The return date (your hearing date)

The back contains the same elements as DC-402: the officer's return of service, venue objection block, and the Notice of Removal section.

Your Response Options

As a defendant served with Form DC-404, you have the same core rights as in any Small Claims Division case:

Appear on the return date. No written answer is required under Va. Code § 16.1-122.3. Show up on the date printed on the form. That's your trial.

Dispute the claim. If you own the property, have a right to possess it, or the plaintiff's description is wrong, present your evidence at the hearing. Bring proof of ownership (title, receipt, gift documentation) and any communications about the property.

Return the property before the hearing. If you agree the property belongs to the plaintiff, you can return it and document the transfer. Get a written, signed receipt. Then verify with the clerk that the plaintiff filed a dismissal — don't assume returning the property cancels the hearing.

File a counterclaim. If the plaintiff owes you money related to the same dispute (for example, they're claiming a vehicle back but owe you for repairs performed on it), file a counterclaim for up to $5,000.

Exercise removal. Your absolute right under Va. Code § 16.1-122.4(B) to move the case to the regular General District Court docket applies equally to detinue actions.

What the Judge Decides

In a detinue trial, the judge determines two things: who has the right to possess the property, and what the property is worth. If the judge rules in the plaintiff's favor, the court orders you to return the specific item. If you can't return it (it's been sold, damaged, or lost), you may be ordered to pay its fair market value instead.

If the judge rules in your favor — you rightfully possess the property — the case is dismissed.

Evidence That Matters in Detinue

Detinue cases turn on ownership and right of possession. The evidence that wins these cases:

• Title documents. Vehicle titles, registration records, equipment serial number documentation.
• Purchase records. Sales receipts, bills of sale, payment confirmations showing you bought the item.
• Gift evidence. Text messages, emails, or witnesses confirming the property was a gift, not a loan.
• Agreement terms. If the property was part of a larger transaction (a security deposit, a lease, a business arrangement), bring the contract showing the terms under which you hold it.
• Condition documentation. Photos of the property showing its current state, especially if the plaintiff is claiming a higher value than the item is worth.

After the Decision

The same post-decision rights apply: 10 calendar days to file a Notice of Appeal for a de novo trial in Circuit Court, 30 days to post the appeal bond, and 30 days to file a Motion for a New Trial if the judgment was entered by default.

The Virginia Small Claims Response Guide covers both Warrant in Debt (DC-402) and Warrant in Detinue (DC-404) actions, with a form decoder and preparation checklist for each.

See more Virginia guides →