Virginia Small Claims Court Counterclaims and Continuances Explained
You filed a claim against someone, and now they're filing a counterclaim against you. Or you've been told the hearing date has been continued to a later date. Both situations are normal parts of the Virginia small claims process — but they catch first-time filers off guard.
How Counterclaims Work in Small Claims
A counterclaim is the defendant's own claim against you, filed within the same case. Under Va. Code §§ 16.1-122.3(F) and 16.1-88.01, a defendant in the Small Claims Division can file a counterclaim up to $5,000; it does not have to arise from the same transaction or occurrence as your original claim.
Example: You sue a contractor for returning your $3,000 deposit after they abandoned the job. The contractor counterclaims for $2,000, arguing they performed work and you refused to pay. Both claims get heard at the same hearing.
The $5,000 Cap Applies to Counterclaims Too
Just like your original claim, a counterclaim in the Small Claims Division cannot exceed $5,000 (exclusive of interest). If the defendant's counterclaim is worth more than $5,000, they can waive the excess and limit it to $5,000 in small claims court, permanently giving up the waived amount; seek removal of the case to the regular General District Court civil docket; or bring a separate action in Circuit Court.
What a Counterclaim Means for You
If the defendant files a counterclaim, you're now both a plaintiff on your original claim and a defendant on theirs. You need to prepare evidence not just to prove your case, but also to defend against theirs.
At the hearing, the judge will hear both claims and may rule in your favor on both, in the defendant's favor on both, or split the decision. If you win $3,000 on your claim and the defendant wins $1,500 on their counterclaim, the judge may enter a net judgment of $1,500 in your favor.
How to Prepare for a Counterclaim
Anticipate the defendant's position before the hearing:
- What justification might they have for keeping your money or not paying?
- Do you have documentation that refutes their likely defense?
- If they claim they performed work, do you have photos, inspection reports, or third-party estimates showing the work was incomplete or defective?
Organize your rebuttal evidence in the same binder system you use for your main claim.
How Continuances Work
A continuance postpones the hearing to a later date. Under Va. Code § 16.1-122.3(E), the parties may agree to change the trial time or the court may order a change, but a continuance may be granted only for good cause shown.
Agreed change of trial time. The parties may agree to change the time set for trial. Confirm any agreed date change with the clerk; the statute separately requires good cause for a continuance.
Good cause shown to the judge. One party demonstrates a legitimate reason why the hearing cannot proceed on the scheduled date — for example, sudden illness or active military service. The court decides whether the specific circumstances show good cause.
Showing Good Cause
Whether a reason meets the good-cause standard is for the court to decide. Explain the specific circumstances and ask the clerk about the court's procedure; don't assume a work or preparation issue will be approved.
The Rescheduled Date
When a continuance is granted, the court sets a new date. Check with the clerk's office for that date — don't assume you'll receive a mailed notice in time.
When Continuances Help You
If the defendant has not been served, the court cannot enter a valid judgment against them. Contact the clerk about the service status and next step rather than assuming the case will automatically be continued.
If you need to subpoena a witness or documents and didn't file the request in time (Forms DC-325 or DC-336 should be filed at least 10 days before the hearing), a continuance gives you a second chance to get the subpoenas served before the new hearing date.
When Continuances Hurt
Every continuance is another day off work, another trip to the courthouse, and another month of waiting. If you're suing for $1,500, the accumulated time costs start to weigh against the recovery.
Corporate defendants sometimes use the continuance-then-removal pattern strategically: request a continuance on the return date, then file a removal notice before the rescheduled hearing. This converts a quick small claims hearing into a longer regular-docket case. There's no way to prevent this, but being aware of the pattern helps you set realistic expectations when suing business entities.
Quick Reference
| Situation | What happens | Your response |
|---|---|---|
| Defendant files a counterclaim ≤ $5,000 | Both claims heard at same hearing | Prepare rebuttal evidence |
| Defendant's counterclaim > $5,000 | Case may be removed to regular docket | Prepare for formal civil rules |
| Parties agree to change trial time | Date is changed by agreement | Confirm the date with the clerk |
| Continuance for good cause | Judge grants, new date set | Use extra time to strengthen evidence |
| Continuance denied | Hearing proceeds as scheduled | Be ready to present your case |
The Virginia Small Claims Filing Guide covers counterclaim strategy and hearing preparation, including how to organize evidence that addresses both your claim and the defendant's potential defenses.
Get Your Free Virginia Small Claims Filing Checklist
Download the Virginia Small Claims Filing Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.