How to Settle a Small Claims Case in South Carolina

Most small claims cases in South Carolina settle before the hearing. A settlement is often the fastest, cheapest, and most predictable way to resolve a dispute — no judge, no testimony, no uncertainty about the outcome. Both sides agree on a number and terms, put it in writing, and the case ends.

But a verbal handshake is not enough. If the settlement is not documented correctly, you can end up right back in court.

When Settlement Makes Sense

Settlement is worth considering when:

• The dispute amount is modest and attorney fees or time off work for a hearing would eat into any recovery
• The facts are mixed — both sides have some merit, making the hearing outcome unpredictable
• You want to preserve a relationship — business partners, neighbors, landlord-tenant situations where you will keep interacting
• Speed matters — a hearing may be weeks or months away, and a settlement resolves it now
• The other side cannot pay a full judgment — collecting 60% now may be worth more than a judgment for 100% that you cannot enforce

Settlement does not mean you were wrong. It means the cost of continuing outweighed the benefit.

How to Negotiate

Either party can propose a settlement at any point after the lawsuit is filed — before the Answer is due, after the Answer, or even at the courthouse on hearing day. There are no formal rules for how the negotiation happens.

Practical approaches:

• Direct contact. Call or email the other party (or their attorney) and propose a number. Keep it factual: "I'm willing to pay $X to resolve this" or "I'll accept $X and dismiss the case."
• Through the court. Some Magistrate Courts offer mediation through the county's alternative dispute resolution program. The mediator does not decide the case — they help both sides reach an agreement. The existing mediation post covers that process in detail.
• At the hearing. Magistrates routinely ask both parties at the start of the hearing whether they have discussed settlement. Some give you time in the hallway to negotiate before proceeding.

Start with what you can document. Keep text messages, emails, and written offers — they become evidence if the settlement falls apart.

Put It in Writing

A settlement agreement should include:

1. The parties' full legal names and the case number
2. The settlement amount — how much, paid by whom, to whom
3. Payment terms — lump sum or installments, and the dates
4. What each side gives up — typically, the plaintiff dismisses the claim and the defendant waives any counterclaim
5. A release of claims — both sides agree not to sue each other again over the same dispute
6. Signatures and date from both parties

If either party is a business entity, the person signing must have authority to bind the company.

Filing the Settlement With the Court

Once both sides sign the agreement, you have two options for closing the case:

Voluntary dismissal. Before the defendant answers or serves a motion for summary judgment, the plaintiff may file and serve a Notice of Voluntary Dismissal. After an Answer or motion for summary judgment, the parties may file a Stipulation of Dismissal signed by all who have appeared, or ask the court to dismiss the case by order. State whether the dismissal is with or without prejudice. If the defendant later fails to pay, the plaintiff would need to file a new lawsuit to enforce the settlement agreement itself — not the original claim.

Consent order. Both parties ask the magistrate to enter the settlement as a court order (a consent judgment). This is stronger: if the defendant does not pay, the plaintiff can enforce the consent judgment directly — through liens and writs of execution — without filing a new lawsuit. This is the better option when the settlement involves future payments.

For installment agreements, always request a consent order. A voluntary dismissal with a side agreement to pay in installments leaves the plaintiff unprotected if payments stop.

What Happens If the Other Side Does Not Follow Through

If there is a consent order and the other side does not pay, the settlement amount is enforceable as a judgment. The plaintiff can pursue standard collection remedies: judgment liens on real property and writs of execution against personal property. South Carolina prohibits wage garnishment for general civil judgments under S.C. Code § 15-39-410.

If the case was dismissed voluntarily and the agreement was breached, the plaintiff must file a new lawsuit — this time for breach of the settlement agreement.

Settlement at Any Stage

You can settle even after a judgment has been entered. After full payment, SCMCR Rule 17(d) requires the judgment creditor to file a statement of collection with the Magistrate Court and with the Circuit Court Clerk if the judgment was previously filed there. Keep written records of any partial payments made under a settlement.

The Responding to a Small Claims Case in South Carolina guide covers settlement strategy alongside the response process — when to negotiate before filing your Answer, how to document the agreement, and how to protect yourself if payments are spread over time.

See more South Carolina guides →