PEI Small Claims Settlement Conference: What Happens Before Trial

What a Settlement Conference Actually Is

After the defendant files their Statement of Defence (Form 9A), the Supreme Court of PEI's Small Claims Section typically schedules a settlement conference before setting a trial date. This is a mandatory step in most contested claims — not something you opt into.

A settlement conference is a structured meeting between both parties and a judge or prothonotary, held in a less formal setting than a courtroom trial. The goal is straightforward: see whether the dispute can be resolved without the time and expense of a full hearing.

Under Rule 74 of the PEI Rules of Civil Procedure, the presiding judge or prothonotary can explore the issues in dispute and encourage compromise. A judge who conducts the settlement conference will not preside over the trial unless the parties consent in writing.

How to Prepare

Bring everything you would bring to trial. That means:

• Your complete file: the Statement of Claim, the defendant's defence, all correspondence between the parties, and any documents attached to either pleading
• A written summary of your position: one page laying out what happened, what you're owed, and what you'd accept to settle
• Proof of your damages: receipts, invoices, repair estimates, bank statements, photographs — the same evidence you'd present at hearing
• A realistic settlement range: know your bottom number before you walk in

The judge will ask each party to explain their position. They may point out weaknesses in your case or the other side's case. This isn't the judge taking sides — it's an honest assessment designed to help both parties understand the risks of going to trial.

What Happens During the Conference

Settlement conferences at the Charlottetown and Summerside courthouses typically last 30 to 60 minutes. The process usually follows this pattern:

1. The judge opens by explaining the purpose and ground rules
2. The plaintiff summarizes their claim and evidence
3. The defendant responds with their position
4. The judge may meet with each party separately (called a "caucus") to discuss settlement options privately
5. If both sides reach agreement, the terms are recorded and become a binding court order
6. If no agreement is reached, the matter proceeds to trial scheduling

A settlement reached at the conference is enforceable the same way a trial judgment is — through garnishment, seizure, or other execution methods available under PEI law. The advantage is that both parties have some control over the outcome, which disappears once a judge decides the case at trial.

When Settlement Fails

If the conference doesn't produce an agreement, the matter proceeds to trial. Under Rule 74.13, the judge or prothonotary may file a memorandum listing issues that remain, matters the parties agreed on, and relevant evidentiary matters; the clerk gives the trial judge a copy. Do not assume everything discussed at the conference remains confidential.

The trial itself follows a more formal process: sworn testimony, cross-examination, and a binding decision by the judge. But many claims do settle at the conference stage, particularly when both parties see the strength of the other side's evidence for the first time.

Should You Make the First Offer?

In most PEI small claims disputes, the plaintiff's opening demand is the full amount claimed. The defendant's opening position is usually zero. The settlement conference exists to find the ground between those two numbers.

If you want a formal offer to have potential costs consequences, use an Offer to Settle (Form 14A) under Rule 74.14 and Rule 49. It must be served at least seven days before trial.

For a complete walkthrough of every step from the demand letter through to collecting your judgment, the PEI Small Claims Filing Guide covers the full process including settlement conference preparation worksheets and evidence organization templates.

Key Takeaways

• Settlement conferences are a standard pre-trial step in contested PEI small claims matters
• The conference judge won't preside at trial unless all parties consent in writing
• Bring your full evidence file and a realistic settlement number
• An agreement at the conference becomes a binding, enforceable court order
• If settlement fails, the court may provide the trial judge with a memorandum of the remaining issues and matters agreed

See more Prince Edward Island guides →