NCAT Respondent Rights and Procedural Fairness

Being named as a respondent does not put you at a disadvantage. NCAT's procedural fairness obligations apply equally to both parties — the applicant carries the burden of proving their claim, and you have full rights to challenge their case.

What Procedural Fairness Means in Practice

NCAT operates under Section 38 of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013, which requires the tribunal to act with as little formality as the circumstances permit while observing the rules of procedural fairness. For respondents, this means:

The right to be heard. You must be given a reasonable opportunity to present your case. If the tribunal proceeds without hearing from you — for example, cutting you off mid-explanation or refusing to let you present evidence — that is a procedural fairness breach.

The right to know the case against you. You should receive the applicant's claim and supporting documents before the hearing. If the applicant produces new evidence at the hearing that you have not seen, you can ask the member for time to review it or for an adjournment.

The right to ask questions. You can ask the applicant and their witnesses about contested facts. The member controls the hearing and may limit or manage questioning.

The right to present evidence. You can submit documents, call witnesses, and make closing submissions. Under Rule 35 of the NCAT Rules, NCAT is not bound by the formal rules of evidence and may inform itself as it sees fit. The member decides what material to accept and what weight to give it.

The Burden of Proof Stays on the Applicant

The applicant must establish the facts supporting the orders they seek. If they allege defective goods, they need to support that allegation with evidence; if they claim unsatisfactory services, they need to show how the work fell below the standard of due care and skill.

As the respondent, you do not need to prove your innocence. You need to present evidence that challenges the applicant's version or shows the work or goods met the required standard. In practice, strong respondent evidence includes the contract or agreement, before-and-after documentation, correspondence showing the customer's awareness and approval, and independent assessments.

When Procedural Fairness Is Breached

A procedural fairness error may be raised in an internal appeal under Section 80 of the Act. An appeal is available as of right on a question of law; an appeal on a question of fact or mixed law and fact requires leave from the Appeal Panel. Examples of concerns to record include:

• The member refused to let you present relevant evidence
• The hearing proceeded before you arrived despite you notifying the registry you were running late
• The member relied on evidence the applicant submitted after the deadline, which you never saw
• The member displayed bias — for instance, expressing an opinion on the merits before hearing your evidence

If you believe procedural fairness was breached during a hearing, note the specific incident immediately (time, what was said, who was present). It may support an appeal, subject to the appeal requirements.

Self-Representation Is the Default

Under Section 45 of the Act, the default position in NCAT consumer claims is that parties represent themselves. A legal practitioner or agent generally needs the tribunal's leave to represent a party; an authorised company officer or employee appearing with written authority is a separate administrative representative. Leave may be sought where the claim has a high monetary value, involves complex legal questions, or where there is a significant imbalance in the parties' ability to present their case.

Self-representation does not mean you are expected to know the law. The member will explain procedural steps as you go. But it does mean you need to come prepared — your evidence organised, your key points identified, and your response to each of the applicant's allegations ready.

The Responding to an NCAT Consumer Claim guide covers respondent rights alongside evidence preparation and hearing procedure worksheets.

See more New South Wales guides →