Michigan Small Claims Witness Rules and How to Subpoena a Witness

Can You Bring Witnesses to Michigan Small Claims Court?

Yes. Both plaintiffs and defendants can bring witnesses to a Michigan small claims hearing. There is no limit on the number of witnesses you can call, but the proceedings are informal and time is limited — most hearings run 15 to 30 minutes — so two or three strong witnesses typically carry more weight than a parade of people repeating the same facts.

A witness in small claims court testifies orally. The magistrate or judge asks questions directly; follow the court's instructions if you have a question for the other party or a witness. Under MCL 600.8411(2), statutory provisions and rules of practice, procedure, pleading, or evidence do not apply in the Small Claims Division, except rules concerning privileged communications. There is no need to lay complex foundations for testimony the way you would in General Civil court.

How to Subpoena a Witness

If a witness agrees to show up voluntarily, a subpoena is not strictly necessary — but voluntary promises fall through, especially when the hearing date conflicts with work schedules. A subpoena is a court order compelling attendance. In Michigan, the process works like this:

1. Get the subpoena form. SCAO Form MC 11 (Subpoena, Order to Appear and/or Produce) is available from the court clerk or the Michigan Courts website. Fill in the witness's name, the case number, the hearing date, time, and location.
2. Have the clerk issue it. Bring the completed form to the District Court clerk's office. The clerk signs and stamps it, making it a valid court order.
3. Serve the subpoena. You may serve it personally through an adult who is not a party, or by registered or certified mail with return receipt requested and delivery restricted to the addressee.
4. Pay the witness fee. The statutory attendance fee is $12 per day or $6 per half-day, or eligible lost work time up to $15 per day, plus mileage. Tender the fees at personal service; with registered or certified mail and acknowledgment, pay the witness after they appear.

For an attendance-only subpoena, MCR 2.506(C)(1) requires service at least 2 days before the appearance; if it requests documents, allow at least 14 days unless the court orders a shorter period. Serve it earlier if your court's instructions set a longer period.

What If a Witness Refuses to Appear?

A witness who has been properly served with a subpoena and fails to appear can be held in contempt of court. In practice, the magistrate will usually grant a continuance so you can re-serve the witness or seek enforcement, rather than ruling without the testimony.

If you cannot serve a witness in time, consider whether their testimony can be presented another way. Written statements carry less weight than live testimony in small claims, but a signed and dated letter describing what the witness observed is better than nothing. Photographs, text messages, and emails from the witness can also support the points you need to make.

Witnesses for Common Defendant Scenarios

Contractor disputes: A second licensed contractor who inspected the work and can testify about defects or code violations. Photographs alone help, but a professional who can explain what went wrong on the stand is harder to dismiss.

Security deposit disputes: A friend or family member who helped with move-out cleaning and can describe the condition of the unit. The 30-day itemization rule under MCL 554.609 is a legal question, but the physical condition of the apartment on move-out day is a factual one that a witness can establish.

Vehicle sale disputes: A mechanic who inspected the vehicle before or after the sale, or the person who was present when the buyer and seller discussed the car's condition.

Practical Tips for Your Witnesses

• Brief your witness on what happened but do not coach them on what to say. The magistrate will notice rehearsed answers.
• Have your witness bring any documents they can speak to — photos they took, invoices they signed, texts they sent.
• Arrive early. Witnesses who are not present when the case is called may miss their opportunity to testify.

A well-prepared witness who saw what happened firsthand is one of the strongest tools a defendant has in small claims court. If you have someone who can corroborate your version of events, get them there.

For a complete walkthrough of hearing preparation, evidence organization, and all five response options available to Michigan defendants, see the Michigan Small Claims Response Guide.

See more Michigan guides →