Manitoba RTB vs. Small Claims Court: Where to File Your Dispute

Filing in the Wrong Place Wastes Time and Money

One of the most common mistakes in Manitoba civil disputes is filing a landlord-tenant claim in Small Claims Court. The Court of King's Bench cannot hear residential-tenancy disputes, so filing in the wrong forum can delay the matter and add filing costs.

The dividing line is clear in Manitoba law: residential tenancy disputes go to the Residential Tenancies Branch (RTB), not the Court of King's Bench Small Claims Court. Getting the forum right the first time saves weeks and avoids lost fees.

The RTB Handles These Disputes

Small Claims Court cannot hear residential-tenancy disputes. The Residential Tenancies Branch handles claims between residential landlords and tenants involving:

• Security deposit returns — the landlord withheld your deposit and you want it back, or a landlord claims the deposit does not cover the damage
• Unpaid rent — a landlord pursuing a tenant for back rent
• Property damage to a rental unit — damage beyond normal wear and tear
• Lease termination disputes — notice periods, early termination, eviction procedures
• Maintenance and repair obligations — a landlord failing to maintain the property
• Unauthorized charges — fees a landlord imposed that the Act does not allow

The RTB process is designed for tenancy disputes, and its hearing officers specialize in residential tenancy law. Under the Residential Tenancies Regulation, a claim for compensation costs $50 if it is not related to a deposit, or if a deposit-related claim seeks more than the deposit and interest. An application for an order of possession costs $60.

How to file with the RTB: Complete the appropriate claim form and follow the Branch's current submission instructions. The published tenant-claim instructions say to submit the completed form with the $50 fee. The fee regulation exempts a deposit-related compensation claim that does not exceed the security deposit and interest. Contact the Residential Tenancies Branch at 204-945-2476 (Winnipeg) or 1-800-782-8403 (toll-free) to confirm which form and fee apply to your claim.

Small Claims Court Handles These Disputes

Small Claims Court can hear monetary claims of up to $20,000, but some types of disputes are excluded even when they are not residential tenancies. The exclusions include ownership of land or an interest in land; administration of a trust or estate; family matters under the Family Division; wrongful dismissal; malicious prosecution, false imprisonment, or defamation; and allegations of wrongdoing by a judge or justice. Check the Manitoba Courts small-claims information page for the full list before filing.

For other non-tenancy money claims, Small Claims Court may be the right forum:

• Commercial landlord-tenant disputes — a business tenant and commercial landlord are not covered by the Residential Tenancies Act
• Contractor disputes related to rental property — if you hired a contractor to renovate a rental and they did poor work, your claim against the contractor is a standard civil dispute, not a tenancy matter
• Former landlord or tenant suing over a non-tenancy debt — for example, a personal loan between people who happen to also have a landlord-tenant relationship
• Property damage between neighbours — one of whom happens to be a tenant. The tenancy relationship is incidental; the dispute is between neighbours

The Grey Areas

Some situations are less obvious:

Subletting disputes: If a tenant sublet the unit and the subtenant caused damage, the head tenant's claim against the subtenant may fall under the RTB (if there is a tenancy relationship between them) or small claims (if the subtenant is being treated as a guest or licensee, not a tenant).

Mixed claims: If your dispute involves both a tenancy component (deposit return) and a non-tenancy component (the landlord's contractor damaged your car in the parking lot), you may need to file the tenancy portion with the RTB and the non-tenancy portion in small claims. The RTB will not hear the car damage claim, and small claims will not hear the deposit claim.

Condo disputes: Disputes between a condo corporation and an owner are not residential tenancies — they are governed by The Condominium Act. Depending on the nature of the dispute, small claims may be the right forum for monetary claims under $20,000.

What Happens If You File in the Wrong Place

Small Claims Court cannot hear a claim involving a residential tenancy. If you have already filed in the wrong forum, contact the court office and the RTB before starting another proceeding; ask what to do with the existing file and any fee you paid.

If your dispute is not a residential-tenancy matter, confirm with the RTB that it can hear the claim before filing there. Do not assume either office will transfer a claim or fee automatically.

Quick Reference

Under the Residential Tenancies Regulation, no RTB filing fee is payable by a person who provides satisfactory confirmation that they receive Manitoba income assistance or the Guaranteed Income Supplement.

For a step-by-step guide to the Small Claims Court process — including forms, service, hearings, and enforcement — the Manitoba Small Claims Filing Guide covers everything you need.

See more Manitoba guides →