How to Prepare for an NCAT Hearing: Evidence, Directions, and What to Expect

After Conciliation Fails: The Directions Phase

When conciliation doesn't resolve your consumer claim, the presiding member issues procedural directions — a formal set of deadlines for preparing and exchanging evidence before the hearing. Standard directions typically require:

• Applicant's evidence: filed and served on the respondent 21 days before the hearing
• Respondent's evidence: filed and served on the applicant 7–14 days before the hearing

These deadlines are strict. If you miss your evidence exchange deadline, the tribunal may refuse to admit your material under the directions for your case. That means the evidence you spent weeks gathering may not be considered.

Building Your Evidence Bundle

Your evidence bundle is the single most important thing you bring to the hearing. NCAT doesn't apply formal rules of evidence in consumer claims, but "informal" doesn't mean "disorganised." A well-structured bundle makes the member's job easier and strengthens your credibility.

Every bundle should include:

An indexed table of contents. Number each document and list it with a short description, its date, and the page range in the bundle. This lets the member and the respondent find documents quickly during the hearing.

A chronological timeline. One page summarising the key dates: when you entered the contract, when goods/services were supplied, when the problem arose, when you complained, when you sent the letter of demand, and when you filed at NCAT.

Contracts and receipts. The written agreement (even if it's just a text message confirmation), quotes, invoices, and proof of payment showing exactly what was agreed and what you paid.

Evidence of the problem. Photos with dates, videos, text messages reporting the defect to the trader, emails, and any written responses from the trader.

Expert reports (if applicable). For complex claims — defective building work, mechanical faults, product failures — an independent inspection report from a qualified professional adds significant weight. The expert must include a declaration that they've read NCAT's Expert Code of Conduct under Procedural Direction 3 and that their duty is to the tribunal, not to whoever commissioned the report. Non-compliant expert reports get thrown out.

Your letter of demand with proof it was sent and received (Registered Post tracking, email read receipts).

Paginate the entire bundle with sequential page numbers. Loose pages without numbers create confusion during cross-examination.

Preparing Witness Statements

Direct evidence at NCAT hearings is submitted primarily in written form — written statements or statutory declarations filed before the hearing. At the hearing itself, witnesses confirm their written statement, then answer questions from the other side and possibly the tribunal member.

If a key witness won't attend voluntarily, you can apply for a summons (A$59 per witness) under Procedural Direction 2. Serve it by the date and time specified in the summons, usually five days before its return date. The issue date, return date, weekends, and public holidays do not count toward those five days. Include conduct money — enough to cover the witness's reasonable travel costs. Without conduct money, the witness can ignore the summons.

Virtual and Phone Hearings

If your hearing is by video link (Audio-Visual Link) or phone, test your setup 15 minutes before the scheduled start. Make sure your camera and microphone work, and have all your documents open and accessible on screen. Witnesses giving evidence remotely must be alone in a quiet room, without coaching or access to documents that haven't been formally admitted.

If you're in regional NSW and attending in person would require significant travel, you can request a virtual hearing through the registry. Do this early — don't assume you'll be offered one.

What Happens at the Hearing

A contested consumer claim hearing follows a predictable sequence:

1. The member opens the hearing, identifies the parties, confirms the issues, and notes which evidence bundles have been filed
2. You present your case: confirm your written evidence, refer to specific documents in your bundle, and explain what happened and what remedy you're seeking
3. The respondent (or their representative) can cross-examine you — ask questions to challenge your account
4. The respondent presents their case and evidence
5. You can cross-examine the respondent
6. Both sides make brief closing submissions summarising how the evidence supports their position
7. The member either delivers a decision on the spot or reserves it for written reasons later

Keep your submissions focused on facts and documents. The member applies the law — your job is to present the evidence clearly and answer questions honestly.

After the Decision

If the member gives an oral decision, you can request formal written reasons within 28 days. If you disagree with the decision, you generally have 28 days from the later of the day you were notified of the decision or the day reasons were first given, orally or in writing, to lodge an internal appeal (A$540 standard fee). Appeals on questions of law are heard as of right; appeals on fact or mixed law/fact require the Appeal Panel's permission.

The NCAT consumer claim guide includes an evidence index cover sheet, hearing day preparation checklist, and directions deadline calendar to keep your preparation on track.

See more New South Wales guides →