How to Collect a West Virginia Landlord Judgment for Unpaid Rent

You won the eviction or rent judgment in West Virginia Magistrate Court. The former tenant owes you $1,500, $3,000, maybe $8,000 in back rent and damages. The court isn't going to collect it for you — that's entirely your job. But as a landlord, you often have one critical advantage over other judgment creditors: you already know where the tenant works (it was on the rental application).

That single piece of information makes wage garnishment the most direct enforcement path. Here's how landlords in West Virginia collect on unpaid rent judgments — and the traps to avoid.

Wait Out the 20-Day Appeal Window

No enforcement document can issue until 20 days after judgment entry. The debtor has 20 days to appeal to Circuit Court or file a motion to set aside the judgment; if an appeal or motion is filed, enforcement is stayed while it is pending.

Mark day 21 on your calendar. Confirm with the Magistrate Court Clerk that no appeal or motion to set aside has been filed. Then you're clear to request enforcement.

Start With Wage Garnishment (Suggestee Execution)

If you know the tenant's employer — and most landlords do, from the lease application or prior communications — a Suggestee Execution is your fastest tool. This is West Virginia's version of wage garnishment, governed by W. Va. Code Chapter 38, Articles 5A and 5B.

How it works:

1. Complete Form SCA-CM640NP (Affidavit for Suggestee Execution) at the Magistrate Court Clerk's office
2. Pay the $5 Magistrate Court fee for the enforcement service; certified mailing costs $1, and county-set Sheriff service or levy fees can be up to $30 under W. Va. Code § 59-1-14
3. For private employers, the Clerk sends the execution by certified mail; if it is unclaimed or refused, service is made as a summons under W. Va. Code § 38-5A-5. Public-employer executions follow Article 5B's service rules
4. The employer or proper public officer begins withholding from the tenant's wages and pays withheld wages over every 90 days under W. Va. Code §§ 38-5A-5(c) and 38-5B-9

How much gets withheld: West Virginia uses a dual test — the employer withholds the lesser of:

• 20% of disposable earnings, or
• the amount by which weekly disposable earnings exceed 50 times the federal minimum hourly wage ($7.25 × 50 = $362.50/week)

On a tenant earning $600/week after taxes, the employer withholds roughly $120/week. A $3,000 judgment is withheld over about 25 weeks, with the employer or proper public officer paying withheld wages over every 90 days.

Bank Garnishment as a Backup

If the tenant is self-employed, works irregular hours, or you don't know their employer, a bank account Suggestion is the alternative. You request a Suggestion order from the Magistrate Court, the Sheriff serves it on the bank, and the bank freezes the account.

The tenant can claim a $1,100 statutory exemption under W. Va. Code § 38-8-1, meaning the first $1,100 in the account is protected. For a tenant with $2,500 in the account, you'd collect $1,400 after the exemption.

Bank garnishment works best when you know which bank the tenant uses — again, this often appears on deposit records or payment histories from the tenancy.

What Tenants Can Claim as Exempt

West Virginia's personal property exemptions protect certain assets from enforcement. The key limits landlords encounter:

• $1,100 bank account exemption — first $1,100 in any bank account
• $15,000 aggregate personal property exemption — applies across all categories of personal property
• Tools of the trade — limited protection for work equipment
• Homestead exemption — protects equity in the debtor's primary residence (relevant only if you're pursuing a real estate lien)

These exemptions don't make the judgment disappear. They limit what you can reach through a single enforcement action. If the tenant's wages exceed the exempt amount, garnishment still works. If the bank account exceeds $1,100, you collect the excess.

Recording a Judgment Lien for Larger Awards

For judgments over $3,000, recording an Abstract of Judgment with the Clerk of the County Commission creates a lien on any real property the tenant owns in that county. The recording fee is $5 per county, and the lien survives for the life of the judgment — 10 years initially, subject to extension through execution or scire facias before expiration.

This matters when a former tenant owns a home or land. The recorded lien encumbers the property and must be addressed to convey clear title or complete a refinance. Even if the tenant doesn't own property today, recording the lien positions you to collect if they acquire property in the future.

Common Landlord Mistakes

Requesting enforcement before the appeal window closes. The Clerk must wait at least 20 days after judgment entry before issuing any enforcement document. Confirm that no appeal or motion to set aside has been filed before requesting enforcement.

Skipping asset discovery. If you've lost track of the tenant's employer, request a post-judgment debtor examination. The tenant must appear under oath and disclose their income, bank accounts, and property. Filing an enforcement tool blind is expensive guesswork.

Ignoring post-judgment interest. The 2026 rate is 6.25% annually, set by the Supreme Court of Appeals. On a $5,000 judgment, that's $312.50 per year accruing in your favor. Track it — it's money the tenant owes you on top of the original judgment.

Accepting informal partial payments without tracking. If the tenant starts paying cash or Venmo without a written agreement, disputes about the remaining balance become your word against theirs. Use a payment tracking worksheet and issue written receipts.

When to Use the Full Collection Guide

The enforcement tools described above are the foundation. The Collecting a Small Claims Judgment in West Virginia guide covers all of them in detail — including the line-by-line form walkthrough for Suggestee Executions, the bank garnishment procedure, the debtor examination process, cross-county enforcement when the tenant moved to a different part of the state, and the Satisfaction of Judgment you're required to file once paid in full.

For a landlord collecting a single rent judgment from a tenant with a known employer, wage garnishment through a Suggestee Execution is typically the beginning and end of the process. The guide makes sure you do it right the first time.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I garnish wages if the tenant moved to another state?

Not directly through West Virginia Magistrate Court. You'd need to domesticate (register) your judgment in the state where the tenant now lives and works, then use that state's garnishment procedures. For judgments under $3,000, this often isn't cost-effective. Recording a West Virginia judgment lien keeps your options open if the tenant returns or acquires property in the state.

What if the tenant is unemployed?

An unemployed debtor has no wages to garnish. Check whether they have a bank account (Suggestion order) or personal property worth seizing (Writ of Execution). If they're truly without assets, they're judgment-proof for now — but the judgment lasts 10 years. People get jobs, open accounts, and buy things. A recorded judgment lien costs almost nothing and waits.

Can I pursue the tenant for attorney fees on top of the judgment?

West Virginia generally follows the "American Rule" — each side pays their own attorney fees unless the lease or a statute specifically provides otherwise. If your lease includes an attorney-fee provision, the court may have already awarded fees as part of the judgment. Otherwise, you're limited to recovering court filing fees and statutory costs.

How quickly does wage garnishment start producing payments?

Once the Suggestee Execution is served, the employer or proper public officer withholds the statutory amount from wages as they become due. Under W. Va. Code §§ 38-5A-5(c) and 38-5B-9, withheld wages are paid over every 90 days; the creditor receives payments on that statutory cycle.

See more West Virginia guides →