How to Prepare an Evidence Bundle for WA Magistrates Court

You have your hearing date. You have a folder full of contracts, invoices, text messages, and photos. The question is how to organise it all so the Magistrate can follow your case without flipping back and forth through loose papers. A well-prepared evidence bundle does more for your credibility than any opening statement.

Why Organisation Matters

Under rule 25C of the Magistrates Court (Minor Cases Procedure) Rules 2005, if the Registrar orders you to lodge and serve a List of Documents, you must do so before trial. Without the court's leave, you cannot tender a document at trial if it was not on your list before the trial began. Springing surprise evidence on the day rarely works — and it makes the Magistrate question whether you have something to hide.

Beyond the procedural requirement, a paginated, indexed bundle tells the Magistrate you are prepared. It lets you say "Your Honour, Tab 3, page 2" instead of shuffling through a pile and holding up the hearing while everyone waits.

How to Structure the Bundle

Organise your documents into categories, then put each category behind a numbered tab divider. A common structure for a minor case claim:

Tab 1 — Formal Documents

• Sealed copy of your Form 4 (Minor Case Claim)
• Your letter of demand and proof of postage (registered post receipt or tracking)
• ASIC company extract or ABN lookup for the defendant (if suing a business)

Tab 2 — The Agreement

• Signed contract, accepted quote, or written terms of trade
• Relevant email or text exchanges showing what was agreed

Tab 3 — Evidence of Breach

• Invoices that remain unpaid (for a debt claim)
• Photos showing damage or incomplete work (for a damages claim)
• Inspection reports or independent assessments

Tab 4 — Financial Records

• Bank statements showing payments you made
• Receipts for repair costs already incurred
• Calculation of the total claimed, broken down line by line

Tab 5 — Communications

• Text messages and emails between you and the defendant, in chronological order
• Any admissions, excuses, or refusals to pay
• The defendant's response to your letter of demand (if they replied)

Number every page in the bundle consecutively — page 1 through to the end, not restarting at each tab. This makes it easy for the Magistrate to reference specific pages in their notes.

Prepare Three Copies

Bring three identical copies of your evidence bundle:

1. Your copy — the one you refer to during the hearing
2. The court's copy — provided to the court orderly if requested
3. The other party's copy — the defendant is entitled to see everything you present

If you are including photographs, print them in colour. Screenshots of text messages should be legible — enlarge them if necessary. Tiny, blurry printouts frustrate everyone.

What to Leave Out

Not everything in your file belongs in the evidence bundle. Leave out:

• Legal arguments and opinions. The bundle is for evidence (facts and documents), not for your interpretation of the law. Save legal points for your closing submissions.
• Duplicate documents. If you have the same invoice saved as a PDF and a screenshot, pick the clearer version.
• Irrelevant correspondence. Include communications about the dispute, not every email you've ever exchanged with the other party.
• Privileged documents. Anything said during a "without prejudice" status conference or settlement negotiation cannot be tendered. If your status conference produced directions but no settlement, those discussions stay out of the trial bundle.

Text Messages and Digital Evidence

Text messages and WhatsApp conversations can form part of the documentary evidence you rely on, but the Magistrate decides whether a particular item is admitted and what weight to give it. Screenshots should show the date, time, and both parties' names or numbers. If the conversation is long, highlight the relevant messages and include only the pages that matter.

For emails, print the full header showing sender, recipient, date, and subject line. If the thread is long, extract the relevant exchanges rather than printing 40 pages of forwards and replies.

Witness Statements

If you are calling a witness — a neighbour who saw the incident, a tradesperson who assessed the damage — arrange for them to attend the hearing in person. The Magistrate hears testimony directly, and the other party can question the witness. Do not assume a written statement from an absent witness will replace live evidence; follow any directions the court gives.

If a witness is reluctant to attend voluntarily, you can apply for a Summons to Witness. The summons must be served personally at least 14 days before the hearing, along with conduct money to cover reasonable travel expenses to the courthouse.

The Day of the Hearing

Arrive early. When the Magistrate invites you to present your case, if the documents have been exchanged as directed, provide the court's copy of the bundle to the court orderly when asked and say something like: "Your Honour, I have prepared an evidence bundle with five tabs. I will refer to specific pages as I present my case." Then walk through the bundle in order, explaining what each key document shows and why it matters.

For a complete guide to preparing for your WA minor case hearing — including evidence checklists, a document index template, and a walkthrough of the hearing itself — the WA Minor Case Claim Guide covers the full process from filing to enforcement.

See more Western Australia guides →