Disputes Tribunal NZ Neighbour and Fencing Disputes: How to File

Your neighbour's tree dropped a branch through your fence, their retaining wall is cracking your driveway, or they're refusing to pay their share for a new boundary fence. These disputes feel personal — which is exactly why the Disputes Tribunal exists. It gives both sides a structured hearing in front of a Referee without the formality, cost, or legal representation of the District Court.

Fencing Disputes Under the Fencing Act 1978

Most neighbour fence disputes in New Zealand are governed by the Fencing Act 1978, which says adjoining occupiers whose land is not divided by an adequate fence are liable to contribute equally to work on a fence, subject to agreements and the Act's exceptions.

To seek a contribution under the Act for proposed fence work, serve your neighbour with a written fencing notice first. The notice must identify the boundary or line where work is proposed, describe the work and materials clearly enough for your neighbour to understand it and estimate the cost, and explain the consequences of not complying. If you propose anything other than an equal split, state each party's share. If your neighbour objects to any proposal, they have 21 days from service of the notice to serve a cross-notice, which may include counter-proposals. If they do not serve a cross-notice within that period, the Act treats them as having agreed to the notice.

If they ignore the notice or you can't agree, the Disputes Tribunal can settle the dispute. It can order the type of fence to be built, divide the costs, and set a timeline for completion. Claims for fencing cost contributions fall comfortably within the Tribunal's $60,000 jurisdictional ceiling (updated 24 January 2026 under the Disputes Tribunal Amendment Act 2025), and the filing fee starts at $62 for claims under $2,000.

Keep your fencing notice and proof of delivery as evidence that you followed the statutory process.

Tree Damage and Property Damage Claims

Overhanging branches, root intrusion, and falling trees cause real damage — broken fences, cracked foundations, flooded drains. When a neighbour's tree damages your property, you can claim the repair cost through the Disputes Tribunal as a tort (property damage) claim.

The key evidence to bring:

• Photographs of the damage and the source tree, dated if possible
• Repair quotes from at least two independent contractors
• Written correspondence showing you notified the neighbour of the problem and asked them to remedy it
• An arborist's report if the damage involves root systems or the neighbour disputes that their tree caused the issue

One common mistake: filing before you've actually quantified the damage. The Referee needs a specific dollar figure, not a vague complaint about the neighbour's trees. Get your quotes first, then file.

What Evidence Wins These Cases

Neighbour disputes run on documentation, not emotion. The Referee isn't interested in a history of grievances — they want to see what happened, what it cost, and what you've already done to resolve it.

Structure your evidence bundle around these three questions:

1. What is the legal obligation? For fencing, that's the Fencing Act notice and the equal-contribution rule. For property damage, it's the duty not to allow your property to cause foreseeable harm to a neighbour's.
2. What damage occurred and what does it cost to fix? Photos, quotes, receipts, and any expert reports.
3. Did you try to resolve it first? Your demand letter, the fencing notice, emails, texts — anything showing you gave the neighbour a reasonable chance to put things right before filing.

Submit your evidence bundle to the Tribunal registry and send a copy to the other party at least five working days before the hearing.

When the Disputes Tribunal Can't Help

Not every neighbour issue belongs at the Disputes Tribunal. Residential tenancy disputes (between landlords and tenants) go to the Tenancy Tribunal under the Residential Tenancies Act 1986. Resource consent or building consent disputes involve the local council or the Environment Court. And if your neighbour's behaviour crosses into harassment or intimidation, contact Police about the conduct; a separate civil claim for loss or damage may still be available.

For genuine property damage, unpaid fencing contributions, or boundary-related money disputes, the Tribunal is the right forum — and you don't need a lawyer to use it. Section 38(7) of the Disputes Tribunal Act 1988 bars legal representation at hearings, so both sides present their own case to the Referee.

The NZ Disputes Tribunal filing guide covers the full process from demand letter through to enforcement, including the evidence preparation worksheet and deadline calendar you'll need for a neighbour dispute claim.

See more New Zealand guides →