Delaware Small Claims Court Mediation: How the JP Court Program Works

Getting served with a civil claim in Delaware Justice of the Peace Court doesn't automatically mean you'll end up in a courtroom arguing your case in front of a magistrate. The JP Court operates a Civil Mediation Unit that gives both sides a chance to resolve the dispute with a neutral third party — before a trial ever happens.

What JP Court Mediation Actually Is

Mediation is a structured conversation between you and the other side, guided by a trained mediator appointed by the court. The mediator doesn't decide who wins or loses. They don't issue orders. Their job is to help both parties communicate, explore options, and see if there's an agreement everyone can live with.

In Delaware JP Court, mediation for standard civil money claims (debt, trespass, replevin) is voluntary. Either party can request it, or the magistrate assigned to your case may suggest it. The only category where mediation is mandatory is summary possession (eviction) cases — regular civil disputes like contractor disagreements, property damage claims, and unpaid invoices go to mediation only if both sides agree or the judge recommends it.

The service is free. You don't pay the mediator or the court for the session.

How to Request Mediation

You can ask for mediation by contacting the JP Court where your case is filed. Let the clerk know you're interested in the Civil Mediation Unit's services. The court will then reach out to the other party to see if they'll participate.

Timing matters. Mediation works best early in the case — after you've filed your Answer (Civil Form 51) but before the trial date. If you wait until the week before trial, there may not be enough time to schedule a session and still prepare for the hearing if mediation falls through.

One important rule: requesting mediation does not postpone your trial date. If mediation is scheduled but hasn't happened yet when your hearing comes up, you still need to appear. Never assume that a pending mediation request gives you permission to skip court.

What Happens During the Session

A typical JP Court mediation session lasts one to two hours. The mediator opens by explaining the ground rules, including how the program handles confidentiality, no interrupting, and the voluntary nature of the process. Then each side gets uninterrupted time to explain their position.

After the opening statements, the mediator may meet with each party separately (called a caucus) to explore settlement ranges privately. The mediator might shuttle between rooms carrying settlement proposals; ask what information may be shared before making a private disclosure.

Bring the same evidence you'd bring to trial: contracts, receipts, photos, text messages, invoices. A mediator who understands the strength of your documentation can help the other side see why a settlement makes sense.

If Mediation Produces an Agreement

When both sides reach a deal, put it in writing. To close the case, file a signed Stipulated Dismissal or Consent Order with the court. Continue to attend scheduled court dates until the court enters the dismissal or order.

The agreement typically covers the dollar amount one side will pay, the payment schedule, and a deadline. A Consent Order entered by the court can be enforced as a court order; a Stipulated Dismissal closes the case, so do not assume that every settlement term can be enforced in the same case.

If Mediation Doesn't Work

Do not assume that communications in every standard civil mediation are confidential or automatically excluded from trial. Confirm the program's confidentiality rules before sharing sensitive information. If you can't reach a deal, your case continues on the court's schedule; keep attending scheduled court dates unless the court tells you otherwise.

Mediation is free and voluntary for standard civil money claims, but ask the mediator about confidentiality before disclosing sensitive information.

When Mediation Makes Sense for Defendants

Mediation tends to work well when both sides have a reasonable claim but disagree on the amount. A contractor suing for $8,000 when you believe the work was worth $4,000 is a classic mediation candidate — there's probably a number in between that avoids the uncertainty of a trial.

It's less useful when one side has no intention of compromising, or when the facts are so clear-cut that a trial would produce a quick result anyway.

If you're a defendant preparing for a Delaware JP Court civil case and want a structured plan for every stage — from your initial response through mediation, trial, and beyond — the Responding to a Small Claims Case in Delaware guide walks through each step with Delaware-specific forms, deadlines, and worksheets.

See more Delaware guides →