Business Defendant Small Claims Court New York

Yes, Businesses Can Be Sued in Small Claims

Under New York law, corporations, LLCs, partnerships, and other business entities cannot file ordinary small claims as plaintiffs. They generally use a Commercial Claims Part under Article 18-A where one is available; Town and Village Justice Courts have no Commercial Claims Part, so an entity claimant must use an appropriate City or District Court or the standard civil part. But business entities can be named as defendants in the ordinary small claims part. A customer, individual vendor, or other eligible claimant with a monetary dispute against your business can sue you in small claims just like they would sue an individual.

This one-way rule surprises many business owners. If a customer sues your LLC in small claims, the case does not move to Commercial Claims just because the defendant is a business. A defendant may still seek transfer to the regular civil part, including through a jury demand.

Who Can Appear for the Business

In regular civil court, CPLR Section 321(a) generally requires corporations to appear through an attorney. Small claims court is different. In the small claims parts of NYC Civil Court, City Courts, District Courts, and Town and Village Justice Courts, a corporate defendant can appear through:

• An authorized officer of the corporation or LLC (such as a president or secretary)
• A director of the corporation
• A designated employee authorized to speak for the business

You do not need to hire a lawyer to defend a small claims case, though you can if you want to. The person who appears must be familiar with the facts of the dispute and authorized to settle or make binding statements on behalf of the business.

Practical Steps After Being Served

When your business receives a small claims Notice of Claim:

Confirm the entity named. Is the plaintiff suing the LLC, the sole proprietorship, or you personally? If the papers name your LLC, the LLC is the defendant and its assets are at stake. If they name you individually, your personal assets could be involved. Sometimes plaintiffs sue both.

Identify the right person to appear. Pick someone who knows the facts — the manager who dealt with the customer, the owner who handled the project, or the employee who was directly involved. That person will present the defense and answer the judge's questions.

Gather business records. Pull the contract or service agreement, invoices, receipts, delivery confirmations, email correspondence with the customer, and any photos or documentation of the work performed or product delivered. Print three copies of everything.

Check counterclaim viability. If the customer actually owes your business money from the same transaction, file a counterclaim within five days of receiving the notice. The fee is $3 to $5 plus postage.

At the Hearing

The hearing works the same as any other small claims case. The plaintiff presents their claim, then the business representative presents the defense. Bring organized, printed evidence. The judge or arbitrator does not care about your business's reputation in the abstract — they care about the specific documents and facts of the transaction at issue.

One thing to watch: if the person who appears for the business was not directly involved in the transaction, the judge may find their testimony less credible than the plaintiff's firsthand account. Send someone who was actually there.

Get Your Business Defense Organized

The Responding to a Small Claims Case in New York guide includes evidence organization worksheets and a hearing day planner that work for business defendants across all four New York court tiers.

See more New York guides →