Yukon Small Claims Dispute Resolution: Mediation, Settlement, and Consent Orders

Three Paths to Resolve a Dispute

Most Yukon small claims cases never reach a full trial. The system is designed to push cases toward resolution at multiple points along the way. As a defendant, you have three main avenues for settling before a judge decides for you.

The Mandatory Pre-Trial Conference

After a Form 02 Reply is filed, any party can ask the court registry to schedule a pre-trial settlement conference (PTC). Both sides must attend once it is scheduled. A Territorial Court judge or Justice of the Peace chairs the meeting in an informal setting, usually a conference room.

The judge reviews both sides' documents, asks questions, and may give a preliminary view of how a trial might go. That assessment often shifts the negotiation. If the judge suggests the plaintiff's damages claim is inflated, the plaintiff has an incentive to settle for less. If your defence has a gap, you might weigh the cost of proceeding against accepting a reduced settlement.

If mediation at the conference resolves the issues, the terms can be filed as a Form 12 Pre-Trial Consent Order. If you settle outside the conference, the parties may apply for a Form 11 Consent Order without a hearing. Once entered, an order is binding and can include payment schedules, lump sums, or specific obligations (return the goods, complete the work).

Court-Connected Mediation

Under Section 40 of the Small Claims Court Regulations, mediation can take place at the pre-trial conference if both parties consent. The presiding judicial officer may mediate the issues, and with the parties' consent may adjourn the conference to continue another day.

The key advantage of mediation is confidentiality. Anything said during mediation can't be used as evidence at trial if mediation fails. This gives both sides room to make concessions and explore creative solutions without worrying that an offer to pay $3,000 will be treated as an admission that you owe at least $3,000.

If mediation at the pre-trial conference produces an agreement, the terms can be filed as a Form 12 Pre-Trial Consent Order. The agreement is unenforceable if it is not filed with the court. If mediation does not resolve the issues, the presiding judicial officer sets a trial date and place with the parties or as directed by a judge.

Direct Settlement Between the Parties

Nothing stops you from settling directly with the plaintiff at any point—before the pre-trial conference, between the conference and trial, or even at the courthouse door. Direct settlement is often faster and gives both sides full control over the terms.

If you settle, document it properly to close the court file. The plaintiff files a Form 25 Notice of Withdrawal to drop the claim. If the settlement involves payment terms or conditions, record those in a Form 11 Consent Order signed by both parties. If you filed a counterclaim, you'll need to withdraw it separately or include its dismissal in the consent order.

An undocumented settlement—a handshake and a cheque—is risky. If the plaintiff later denies the settlement happened and proceeds with the lawsuit, you'll need to prove the agreement existed. Always get it in writing and filed with the court.

When Settlement Isn't the Right Move

Settlement makes sense when the cost and stress of a trial outweigh the difference between what you'd pay in a settlement and what you might owe after a judgment. But if the plaintiff's claim is entirely without merit—they're suing for work they never performed, or for an amount you can prove was already paid—going to trial may be the better option. A judgment in your favour dismisses the claim and can result in the plaintiff paying your costs.

The Responding to a Small Claim in Yukon guide covers all three resolution paths and includes a settlement evaluation worksheet to help you calculate your best and worst-case outcomes before negotiating.

See more Yukon guides →