How to File a Small Claims Appeal in Wyoming: Notice, Bond, and District Court Transfer

The judge just ruled against you in Circuit Court, and you think the decision got the law wrong. You have exactly 30 calendar days from the date the Judgment and Order (Form SC 06) is entered on the docket to file a Notice of Appeal. If you miss that deadline, you lose the right to appeal.

Here's every step in the appeal process, including what it costs and how to keep the plaintiff from collecting while the appeal is pending.

Filing the Notice of Appeal

You file the Notice of Appeal with the Circuit Court Clerk in the same county that heard your small claims case. Under W.R.A.P. 2.01, also serve a copy on the District Court Clerk and the other parties when you file. The Circuit Court Clerk prepares and transmits the record to the District Court.

Wyoming doesn't publish a pre-printed small claims appeal form. Your Notice of Appeal must identify the party appealing, the Judgment and Order being appealed, and the District Court. Under W.R.A.P. 2.05, include a certificate stating whether you ordered a transcript or will provide an alternate record. The civil-case appendix required by Rule 2.07 must list, but not attach, pleadings asserting claims or adding/removing parties, orders and judgments disposing of claims, and the final judgment and any trial-court decision letter.

File the notice in person at the clerk's office or by mail. File the required appeal and record-preparation fees with it, or submit the motion and supporting documents required to request in forma pauperis status under W.R.A.P. 2.09.

What the Appeal Costs

Three separate fees are due when you file:

• $100 District Court docketing fee — paid through the Circuit Court Clerk, who forwards it when the record is complete
• $100 Circuit Court appellate and docketing fee — the Circuit Court's fee for an appeal to District Court
• $20 record-preparation fee — paid to the Circuit Court Clerk when you file the notice

These three fees total $220, before any transcript costs. That's a significant jump from the $10 it cost the plaintiff to file the original small claims case. If you can't afford the fees, W.R.A.P. 2.09(a) allows you to file a motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis, a proposed order, and an affidavit documenting your inability to pay. Under Rule 2.09(b), a civil appeal may proceed without fees only when a statute or constitutional right allows it.

The Appeal Bond

Filing a Notice of Appeal does not automatically stop the plaintiff from enforcing the judgment against you. They can still pursue collection — bank levies, wage garnishment, property liens — while your appeal works through the system.

To stay execution, W.S. § 5-9-142 requires a bond with an amount and sufficient surety approved by the District Court judge or clerk. The bond must secure the judgment entered on appeal, or the Circuit Court judgment if the appeal is not perfected, and any costs and damages awarded in District Court.

W.S. § 5-9-142 does not provide for a stay without the required bond. The safest approach is to assume enforcement continues unless you have a signed stay order in hand.

What District Court Actually Reviews

This is where most appeals run into trouble. A small claims appeal to District Court is not a new trial. Under Small Claims Rule 7, the review is limited to questions of law on the existing record. The District Court judge reads the transcript and exhibits from your Circuit Court hearing. No new witnesses, no new evidence, no second chance to tell your side of the story.

The appeal succeeds when the small claims judge made a legal error — applied the wrong statute, miscalculated damages as a matter of law, entered judgment despite defective service, or exceeded the $6,000 jurisdictional limit. It fails when the real complaint is "the judge believed the other side's version of events." Factual findings are not reweighed on appeal.

Timeline After Filing

Once the record is prepared, the Circuit Court Clerk transmits it to the District Court. The parties file written briefs under the appellate rules, explaining the claimed legal errors and responding. Ask the District Court Clerk for the briefing dates and whether oral argument will be scheduled.

The entire process typically takes several months from filing to decision. During that time, the judgment accrues post-judgment interest at 10% per annum under W.S. § 1-16-102(a) unless your contract specified a different rate.

When an Appeal Makes Sense

Run a simple cost-benefit check. The $220 in fees plus months of waiting makes sense for judgments in the $2,000–$6,000 range where you can identify a specific legal error in the judge's reasoning. For a $400 judgment where you just disagree with how the judge weighed the testimony, the math doesn't work — and neither does the legal standard.

If you're considering an appeal alongside a Motion to Set Aside Default Judgment under Rule 60(b), note that the two run on separate tracks. The 30-day appeal deadline doesn't pause while a set-aside motion is pending. File the Notice of Appeal within 30 days to preserve the option, then pursue both paths in parallel.

For a complete timeline tracker that maps the 30-day appeal window against your other post-judgment deadlines, get the Wyoming small claims response guide.

See more Wyoming guides →