Vermont Small Claims Settlement: Agreements, Payment Plans, and Dismissals

Small claims cases in Vermont can settle before a hearing. The tricky part is not reaching an agreement — it is making sure the court actually closes the case afterward. Paying the plaintiff directly without filing the right paperwork leaves the lawsuit open, and that can still result in a default judgment against you.

Settlement Options

Lump-sum payment. You and the plaintiff agree on a dollar amount, you pay, and the plaintiff files a dismissal with the court. Straightforward — as long as the dismissal actually gets filed.

Installment plan. If you cannot pay all at once, you can propose a schedule with specific dollar amounts and dates. On Form 100-00126 (the Answer form), there is a dedicated box for this. The court enters judgment based on your proposed terms. If the plaintiff objects, a hearing is scheduled to set an enforceable payment schedule.

Partial payment with a reduced balance. You negotiate paying less than the full amount in exchange for the plaintiff dropping the case. This works when the plaintiff would rather get something certain now than risk a hearing outcome.

How to Make It Official

A verbal agreement or a handshake is not enough. The court needs paperwork. Two instruments work:

Stipulated Dismissal. A joint filing where both parties ask the court to dismiss the action. It can be "without prejudice" (allowing the plaintiff to refile if you do not follow through) or "with prejudice" (permanently ending the case). This is the cleanest way to close a settled case.

Stipulated Agreement / Agreed Judgment. A signed document outlining specific payment terms. Filing this allows the court to enter an enforceable judgment reflecting those terms. If you later miss payments, the plaintiff can enforce the judgment through garnishment or levies without filing a new lawsuit.

The Biggest Settlement Mistake

Paying the plaintiff and assuming the case disappears. It does not. If no judgment has been entered, make sure a formal dismissal or written agreement is filed; without one, the case remains open and the plaintiff could still request a default judgment. If a judgment has been entered and paid in full, the plaintiff must file Form 100-00290 within 21 days.

After a judgment is paid in full, confirm that the plaintiff files Form 100-00290 within 21 days. If they do not, you can file a written request asking the court to enter a satisfaction of judgment. The court gives the plaintiff 21 days to object; if they do not, the judgment is marked paid.

Mediation

Small claims cases are exempt from Vermont's mandatory civil mediation. However, you can voluntarily request mediation at any point before trial. Some court units offer free settlement conferences or community mediation referrals on the day of the hearing.

To set up formal mediation, both parties file a joint Stipulation for Mediation identifying the mediator, fee arrangements, and a completion deadline. This can happen alongside — not instead of — the regular court timeline.

Settlement Negotiations Do Not Pause Deadlines

This is critical. While you are talking settlement, your 30-day Answer deadline keeps running. A scheduled hearing date stays on the calendar. You are still required to appear at trial unless a signed dismissal or a judge's written continuance has been entered on the docket.

Do not rely on the plaintiff telling you the hearing is canceled. Until you see a filed court order, act as though every deadline and hearing date is live.

Under Vermont's evidence rules (V.R.E. 408), evidence of settlement offers and statements made during compromise negotiations generally cannot be used to prove or disprove the validity or amount of a disputed claim. The rule does not make every settlement communication confidential, and exceptions apply.

For worksheets covering settlement tracking, installment calculations, and dismissal procedures, the Responding to a Small Claims Case in Vermont guide walks through every step from negotiation to court closure.

See more Vermont guides →