How to Respond to a Small Claims Case in Vermont

Someone just handed you court papers. A Vermont small claims complaint, complete with a docket number, a dollar amount, and a deadline you didn't ask for. The good news: responding is a structured process with clear steps, and you have 30 days to do it.

What "Responding" Actually Means in Vermont

Responding to a Vermont small claims case means filing a written Answer — specifically, the Small Claims Answer form (Form 100-00126) — with the Superior Court Civil Division clerk in the county listed on your summons. This is not optional. If you miss the applicable Answer deadline, the plaintiff may ask the court for a default judgment. If the complaint was first served by mail, the plaintiff must complete personal service after the initial 30-day period before seeking default.

Form 100-00126 gives you three options. You can dispute the claim by checking "I disagree" and writing a brief explanation of why. You can agree and either pay within 30 days or propose an installment plan. Or you can file a counterclaim if the plaintiff actually owes you money from the same dispute.

You do not need a lawyer to file your Answer. Under 12 V.S.A. § 5536, individuals can represent themselves in Vermont small claims court. But you do need to follow the court's filing rules exactly.

The Five Steps to File Your Answer

Step 1: Verify your paperwork. Confirm your service packet includes the Summons, the Complaint (Form 100-00257), the Instructions for Defendant (Form 100-00259), a blank Answer form (Form 100-00126), a blank Disclosure of Exempt Income form (Form 100-00128), and copies of the plaintiff's supporting documents. If anything is missing, call the Civil Division clerk listed on your summons.

Step 2: Complete Form 100-00126. Check the box that matches your response — disagree, agree, or counterclaim. If disputing, write a short factual explanation. Keep it plain: "The contractor did not finish the work described in the contract" is better than a three-page essay.

Step 3: File your Answer with the court. You have four options: deliver it in person during business hours (8:00 AM–4:30 PM, Monday–Friday), mail it to the county courthouse, email a flattened PDF to the court's designated email address, or file electronically through Odyssey File & Serve. E-filing carries a $14.00 one-time fee per case, plus a 2.89% credit-card processing fee or a $1.00 eCheck charge.

Step 4: Serve a copy on the plaintiff. Filing with the court is not enough. On the same day you file, you must send a copy of your Answer to the plaintiff (or their attorney) by first-class mail, email, or hand delivery.

Step 5: File a Certificate of Service. Complete Form 100-00260 to certify that you served the plaintiff, and submit it to the court at the same time as your Answer.

What Happens After You File

If you disputed the claim, the court clerk schedules a hearing and mails everyone a notice with the date and location. If you agreed and proposed installment payments, the court enters judgment — but if the plaintiff objects to your payment plan, a hearing gets scheduled to sort out the terms.

The hearing itself is relatively informal. The judge hears both sides, reviews evidence, and either rules on the spot or mails a written decision within a few weeks.

Common Mistakes That Cost Defendants

The biggest one: paying the plaintiff directly and assuming the case disappears. It does not. If no judgment has been entered, make sure a formal dismissal or written agreement is filed; if a judgment has been entered and paid in full, the plaintiff must file Form 100-00290 within 21 days.

Another common mistake is calling the court clerk to explain your side. Clerk staff handle administrative questions — filing deadlines, courthouse hours, fee amounts — but they cannot give legal advice or evaluate your defense. A phone call does not count as a filed Answer.

If you need help deciding how to respond, Vermont Legal Aid and VTLawHelp.org offer free tools including the VTCourtForms guided interview that walks you through Form 100-00126 step by step.

For a complete walkthrough of the entire response process — from reading your complaint packet through the hearing and beyond — the Responding to a Small Claims Case in Vermont guide covers every step with worksheets for deadline tracking, evidence organization, and hearing preparation.

See more Vermont guides →