Can You Appeal a VCAT Decision? Review, Rehearing, and Supreme Court Options

The Short Answer

You can challenge a VCAT decision, but the routes are narrow and each one has strict requirements. VCAT is designed to produce final, binding outcomes — the system deliberately makes it difficult to re-litigate matters that have already been heard.

Your options depend on what went wrong: whether you were absent when the order was made, whether the Member made a legal error, or whether you simply disagree with the outcome.

Option 1: Section 120 — Reopening an Order Made in Your Absence

If you did not appear at the hearing and were not represented, Section 120 of the VCAT Act is the correct pathway for an order made against you. This is not an appeal — it asks VCAT to review the order and rehear the case.

Your application must arrive at VCAT within 14 days of becoming aware of the order, and you must satisfy a four-part test: timely application, reasonable excuse for absence, a case worth hearing, and no unreasonable prejudice to the other party.

Section 120 only applies when you did not appear and were not represented. If you or your representative attended the hearing, this route is not available.

Option 2: Appeal to the Supreme Court

Under Section 148 of the VCAT Act, a party can appeal a VCAT decision to the Supreme Court of Victoria — but only on a question of law. This means the Member applied the wrong legal test, misinterpreted a statute, or made a procedural error that affected the outcome.

Disagreeing with how the Member weighed the evidence is not a question of law. Thinking the Member believed the wrong witness is not a question of law. These are findings of fact, and the Supreme Court will not interfere with VCAT's fact-finding role.

Appeals to the Supreme Court are expensive (filing fees start in the hundreds of dollars, and legal representation is standard), time-consuming (months, not weeks), and unlikely to succeed unless there is a clear legal error. For small claims worth a few thousand dollars, the cost of an appeal often exceeds the amount in dispute.

You need leave (permission) from the Supreme Court to bring the appeal, and the application for leave must be filed within 28 days of the VCAT order.

Option 3: Request Written Reasons

Before deciding whether to appeal, request written reasons for the decision. If the Member gave an oral decision at the hearing and you did not ask for written reasons at the time, you have 14 days from the date of the decision to request them under Section 117 of the VCAT Act.

Written reasons explain the Member's reasoning — which evidence they accepted, which legal principles they applied, and why they reached their conclusion. Without written reasons, an appeal is almost impossible because you cannot identify the legal error.

Option 4: Judicial Review (Rare)

In exceptional cases, a party can seek judicial review of a VCAT decision in the Supreme Court. This is not an appeal on the merits — it challenges whether VCAT had jurisdiction to hear the matter, whether the proceedings were procedurally fair, or whether the decision was so unreasonable that no rational tribunal could have reached it.

Judicial review is the most expensive and least likely option to succeed. It is typically relevant only when there is a fundamental procedural failure — for example, VCAT heard the case without giving you any notice or opportunity to respond.

What You Cannot Do

You cannot simply ask VCAT to rehear the case because you disagree with the outcome. If you attended the hearing, presented your evidence, and lost, the decision is final unless there is a legal error worth appealing.

You cannot appeal to the County Court. VCAT decisions are appealed to the Supreme Court, not the County Court.

You cannot use Section 120 if you attended or were represented at the hearing. The reopening mechanism is only available when an order was made while you did not appear and were not represented.

Practical Advice

For most self-represented parties in small consumer disputes, the cost of a Supreme Court appeal ($5,000–$20,000+ in legal fees, depending on complexity) dwarfs the amount at stake. Before pursuing an appeal, honestly assess:

• Is there a genuine legal error, or do you just disagree with the result?
• Is the amount in dispute large enough to justify the cost?
• Would a lawyer confirm that the appeal has reasonable prospects?

If you are still in the response stage — preparing your defence, gathering evidence, or heading toward a hearing — the time to build the strongest possible case is now, not after the decision. The VCAT response guide covers every step of the process from the respondent's perspective.

See more Victoria guides →