Sued by a Contractor in Florida Small Claims Court — What to Do

A contractor files a Statement of Claim against you for unpaid work — maybe $3,000 for a bathroom remodel you say was never finished, or $5,500 for materials you believe were defective. Contractor-versus-homeowner disputes are among the most common cases in Florida small claims court, and the claims regularly approach the $8,000 jurisdictional ceiling, excluding court costs, accrued interest, and statutory or contractual attorney fees.

Your First Steps After Being Served

Don't panic, and don't ignore the papers. Your immediate priorities:

1. Read the summons carefully. Identify your Pretrial Conference date (set within 50 days of the filing). This is when you must appear — in person or virtually, depending on your county.

2. Determine whether a written answer is necessary. Under Rule 7.090(c), a written response is generally optional unless the court orders one. You can state your position verbally at the pretrial conference. A written sworn venue objection should be filed at least 7 days before the court date, or raised orally at the pretrial conference; check the deadline for any other motion or court order.

3. Decide whether you have a counterclaim. If the contractor left the job incomplete, used substandard materials, or caused damage to your property, you may have a claim against them arising from the same project. That makes it a compulsory counterclaim under Rule 7.100, and it must be filed at least 5 days before the pretrial conference unless the court designates another time. An untimely compulsory counterclaim is abandoned, permanently barring a later independent lawsuit over the same claim.

Evidence That Matters

Contractor disputes live and die on documentation. Start gathering:

• The original contract, estimate, or written agreement. If there was no written contract, that's actually relevant — Florida statute and case law address oral agreements and reasonable-value claims differently.
• Change orders. Did the scope change mid-project? Written change orders or even text messages agreeing to additional work can show whether the contractor's claim reflects the actual agreed scope.
• Payment records. Bank statements, cancelled checks, Venmo/Zelle receipts showing what you've already paid.
• Photos and videos. Document the current state of the work — unfinished areas, defects, damage. Date-stamped photos are strongest.
• Inspection reports. If you had the work inspected by another contractor, a county building inspector, or a licensed professional, those findings carry weight.
• DBPR license verification. Check and preserve the contractor's licensing information through the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation; licensing status is one fact to document in the dispute.
• Communication records. Texts, emails, and voicemails between you and the contractor showing disputes, complaints, or failed attempts to resolve the issue.

Organize everything using the three-copy rule: one set for you, one for the judge, one for the contractor.

Common Defense Strategies

At mediation and trial, homeowner defendants in contractor disputes typically argue one or more of the following:

Incomplete or defective work. The contractor didn't finish the job or the quality falls below what was reasonably expected given the contract and the price.

Overbilling. The contractor is charging for work not performed, materials not used, or scope beyond what was agreed.

Breach of contract by the contractor. The contractor violated the terms of the agreement — missed deadlines, abandoned the project, or substituted inferior materials without consent.

No written contract / unjust enrichment. If there is no written contract, organize any estimates, messages, invoices, payment records, and evidence of the work actually completed.

The Pretrial Conference and Mediation

When you arrive, the court will likely send both parties to mediation first. This is where the majority of contractor disputes settle. Come prepared with a clear number — what you think the work was actually worth, minus what you've already paid — and be ready to negotiate.

If mediation fails, the court sets a trial date within 60 days. At trial, you'll present your evidence and witnesses. The judge decides unless a jury trial was properly demanded.

Protect Your Position

The Florida Small Claims Response Guide includes an evidence organizer worksheet designed for dispute scenarios like contractor claims, plus a response strategy planner that helps you evaluate whether to dispute, settle, or counterclaim before you walk into court.

See more Florida guides →