Sue Landlord Small Claims Court New York

Your landlord kept your security deposit, won't return your calls, and you're wondering whether small claims court is worth the trouble. In most cases — especially in New York — it is. The filing fee is $10 to $20, depending on the court and claim amount; you don't need a lawyer, and the law is strongly on the tenant's side.

Venue: File Where the Property Is

New York has a special venue rule for tenant security deposit claims. You can file in the court where the rental property is located, even if your landlord lives, works, or operates somewhere else in the state. This is a statutory exception under NYCCCA § 1801, UCCA § 1801, UDCA § 1801, and UJCA § 1801 — it prevents landlords from forcing you to chase them across the state.

Pick the right court tier based on where the property sits:

• NYC (any borough): NYC Civil Court — $10,000 cap
• City outside NYC (e.g., Buffalo, Rochester, Yonkers): City Court — $5,000 cap
• Nassau County or Western Suffolk: District Court — $5,000 cap
• Town or village: Town/Village Justice Court — $3,000 cap

Name the Right Defendant

This sounds obvious but gets people dismissed. If your landlord is an LLC or corporation, you must sue the legal entity, not the property manager's first name. Search the New York State Department of State Corporation and Business Entity Database to find the exact registered name.

If your landlord operates under a "doing business as" (d/b/a) name, find the individual or entity behind it through the County Clerk's assumed name records. File against "Jane Smith d/b/a Sunset Apartments," not just "Sunset Apartments."

The Evidence That Wins Deposit Cases

When GOL § 7-108(1-a) applies, a landlord who misses the 14-day return deadline has forfeited the right to retain any portion of the deposit. Bring:

• Your lease — proves the tenancy and the deposit amount
• Proof of deposit payment — cancelled check, bank transfer record, or a signed receipt
• Move-out photos — showing the condition you left the apartment in, dated and printed
• Your demand letter — the certified mail receipt proves you tried to resolve it before filing
• The landlord's itemized statement (if you got one) — so you can challenge specific deductions
• Comparable evidence for deductions you're disputing — if the landlord claims floor damage, bring photos showing the floors at move-in and move-out

If the landlord never sent an itemized statement within 14 days, and GOL § 7-108(1-a) covers your rental, point this out clearly. Under subsection (e), failure to provide a timely accounting means the landlord forfeits the right to retain any portion of the deposit.

What You Can Recover

You can recover the full deposit amount up to the court's cap. Keep in mind that the court awards money only — it cannot order the landlord to do anything else (like fix an apartment or write a reference letter). If your deposit exceeds the small claims cap, you can waive the excess and sue for the maximum, or file in regular civil court for the full amount.

You can also ask the judge to include your filing fee and service costs in the judgment.

What to Expect at the Hearing

The hearing is informal. You'll explain when you moved out, how much the deposit was, whether you received an itemized statement, and present your evidence. The landlord gets to respond and present their evidence of damages.

If the landlord doesn't show up, the judge conducts an inquest — you still need to present your evidence to prove your claim. A default doesn't mean automatic victory; you need to make your case even when the other side isn't there.

Our Filing a Small Claims Case in New York guide walks through the entire tenant deposit recovery process — from sending the demand letter through presenting your evidence at the hearing — with worksheets for calculating your claim and preparing your exhibit binder.

See more New York guides →