Small Claims Court Mediation in Illinois: What to Know Before Your Session

How Mediation Fits Into Illinois Small Claims Cases

Mediation is a structured negotiation session where a neutral third party helps you and the other side reach a settlement. In Illinois small claims court, local rules and court orders determine whether mediation is offered or required.

The mediator does not decide your case. Their role is to facilitate a conversation that might lead to a deal both sides accept. If mediation fails, the case proceeds to trial.

Local Mediation Rules

Mediation requirements and procedures are local. McLean County (11th Judicial Circuit) has a court-annexed small claims program under Local Rule 109; self-represented litigants are offered mediation on the first return date, and participation requires the parties' agreement.

Other circuits offer voluntary mediation programs or judge-ordered mediation at the first status call. Check with the circuit clerk in your county to find out whether mediation is part of the standard small claims process or available on request.

Some court-annexed programs use trained volunteer mediators and charge no mediation fee; ask the local program about costs. If you have a fee waiver, it covers court-annexed mediation fees as well.

What Happens During the Session

The mediator introduces the process, then each side takes turns explaining their position. After the opening statements, the mediator may meet with each side separately — these are called "caucuses" — to explore whether there is room for compromise. Session length depends on the local program and the case.

Common outcomes:

• Full settlement. Both sides agree on a dollar amount and submit an agreed order or dismissal to the court. The case is closed when the court enters the appropriate order.
• Partial settlement. The parties agree on some issues but not the full amount. The remaining dispute goes to trial.
• No agreement. The mediator reports an impasse, and the case returns to court for trial.

Confidentiality rules depend on the mediation program. Ask the mediator which communications are protected before sharing sensitive information.

Should You Settle?

Mediation makes sense when the facts are murky or when collection would be difficult even with a judgment. A defendant who agrees to pay $600 today may be worth more than a $900 judgment you spend months trying to collect.

It is less appealing when your evidence is strong, the amount is clear-cut, and the defendant has identifiable assets. In those cases, a trial may get you the full amount plus post-judgment interest at the standard rate of 9% per year, or 5% for consumer debt judgments of $25,000 or less.

If you reach a settlement, make sure the agreement specifies the payment amount and deadline, then file an agreed order or dismissal with the court as appropriate.

Preparing for Mediation

Bring the same evidence you would bring to trial — the contract, payment records, photos, demand letter, and repair estimates. Even though mediation is informal, showing organized proof strengthens your negotiating position.

Know your bottom line before you walk in, but keep it to yourself. The mediator may ask what you would accept, and having a clear number prevents you from agreeing to something you regret.

For a complete walkthrough of the Illinois small claims process, including preparing for both mediation and trial, see the Illinois Small Claims Filing Guide.

See more Illinois guides →