Settlement Conference in Small Claims Court in Newfoundland and Labrador

Every Disputed Claim Goes Through a Settlement Conference First

If you filed a Reply (Form 2) disputing all or part of a claim in Newfoundland and Labrador's Provincial Court, Small Claims Division, you don't go straight to trial. Under Rule 10 of the Small Claims Rules, the court automatically schedules a mandatory settlement conference — a judge-led meeting where both sides try to resolve the dispute without a formal hearing.

The registry sends a Notice of Settlement Conference to both parties at least 14 days before the scheduled date. Attendance is not optional.

What Actually Happens at the Conference

The settlement conference is less formal than a trial but more structured than a conversation. Here's the typical sequence:

The judge reviews the file. The presiding Provincial Court judge reads the Statement of Claim (Form 1) and your Reply (Form 2) before the conference begins, so both sides' positions are already on the table.

Each side explains their position. The judge asks the plaintiff to outline their claim and you to outline your defence. This isn't testimony under oath — it's a summary to identify the real issues and see where the parties disagree.

The judge probes for common ground. The judge may point out strengths and weaknesses in each side's position, suggest compromise numbers, or propose creative solutions (like a partial payment plan or specific repair work).

Procedural housekeeping. The judge may resolve preliminary issues — setting document exchange deadlines, allowing amendments to pleadings, or clarifying which witnesses each side plans to call.

The conference is confidential. Nothing said during settlement discussions can be used against either party at trial if the case doesn't settle.

How to Prepare

Showing up prepared makes a significant difference in how the conference goes and whether you walk out with a resolution:

Organize your documents. Bring every relevant document you have: contracts, invoices, text messages, emails, photographs, repair estimates. Rule 9 of the Small Claims Rules requires you to file a list of documents with the court and serve the list and copies of the documents on the other side at least 3 days before the settlement conference. Don't wait until the day of — serve your document package early and keep proof of delivery.

Know your numbers. If there's a dollar figure in dispute, understand exactly how it breaks down. If the plaintiff claims $8,000 in renovation damages, what specifically do they say was damaged and what would repairs actually cost? If you're disputing the amount rather than the entire claim, know what figure you'd accept.

Think about settlement ranges. The judge will push both sides toward compromise. Before you walk in, decide your range: what would you accept to settle, and what's your walk-away number? Having this figured out beforehand keeps you from making decisions under pressure.

Bring authority to settle. If you're representing a corporation or partnership, Rule 10(4) requires your representative to have full authority to negotiate a binding settlement. A representative who has to "check with the owner" cannot meaningfully participate, and the judge won't be pleased.

If You Reach an Agreement

When both parties agree to terms, the settlement is documented in one of several ways:

• A written settlement agreement that both sides sign
• A consent judgment (Form 17) entered by the court, which is enforceable like any other court judgment
• An Offer to Settle (Form 8) that one side accepts

If the agreement involves installment payments — say, paying $6,000 over six months — the judge can issue an installment judgment under Rule 15 without a separate hearing.

Once a settlement agreement is filed, it's binding. If one party later breaks the terms (other than a payment schedule), the other party can apply under Rule 10(18) for an immediate court order enforcing the agreement.

If You Don't Reach an Agreement

If the settlement conference doesn't produce a resolution, the judge:

1. Sets firm deadlines for any remaining document exchange
2. Schedules a trial date
3. May give directions about witnesses, the expected length of the hearing, and any issues that need to be addressed before trial

The same judge who conducted the settlement conference does not preside over the trial unless the parties agree. This is an important procedural protection — anything said during confidential settlement discussions stays out of the courtroom.

Can You Amend Your Reply Before the Conference?

Yes. Under Rule 11(1)(a), either party can amend their pleadings — the Statement of Claim or the Reply — without permission before the settlement conference starts. If you realize after filing Form 2 that you left out an important fact or want to adjust your counterclaim amount, you can file an amended version before the conference.

Once the conference begins, amendments require the judge's permission under Rule 19(3).

Our Responding to a Small Claim in NL guide includes a settlement conference preparation checklist, a document exchange tracker for the 3-day Rule 9 deadline, and practical guidance on evaluating settlement offers.

See more Newfoundland and Labrador guides →