How to Settle a Small Claims Case in Washington Before the Hearing

Most small claims cases in Washington settle before trial. A direct agreement between the parties avoids the uncertainty of a judge's ruling, saves time, and costs nothing extra. But the settlement process has a procedural trap that catches people every year: paying the plaintiff doesn't automatically cancel the lawsuit.

The Written Notice Requirement

Under Washington court rules, when parties settle a small claims case before the hearing, both must notify the court clerk immediately in writing. The clerk then cancels the hearing and enters an Order of Dismissal.

If you pay the plaintiff directly but neither of you files written notice with the court, the hearing stays on the calendar. If nobody shows up, the court can still enter a default judgment — even though the money has already changed hands.

Write a letter to the clerk identifying the case number, stating that the claim has been settled, and ask both parties to sign it. Keep a copy. A dismissal that exists only as a verbal agreement between you and the plaintiff isn't worth the paper it isn't written on.

Direct Negotiation

You can contact the plaintiff directly to discuss settlement at any time before the hearing. Common terms include:

• Full payment of the claimed amount in exchange for a signed dismissal request
• Partial payment if you dispute part of the claim and the plaintiff would rather take a guaranteed amount than risk losing at trial
• Payment plan with agreed installments and a default clause

Put the terms in writing. Even a simple document stating "Plaintiff agrees to dismiss Case No. [X] upon receipt of $[amount] by [date]" protects both sides. Without written terms, a settlement can unravel into a second dispute.

Court-Connected Mediation

Washington courts are authorized under RCW 12.40.030 to use dispute resolution services before trial. Mediation is facilitated through Dispute Resolution Centers (DRCs) established under Chapter 7.75 RCW.

In King County, pre-trial mediation through the King County Dispute Resolution Center (KCDRC) is mandatory — you'll attend a mediation session before the judge schedules any trial. Sessions run on Zoom.

Spokane County offers optional Dispute Resolution Center mediation. Check your court's rules for the mediation process in other counties. Resolution Washington maintains a statewide network of DRC member centers.

Key facts about mediation:

• Mediators are neutral. They facilitate negotiation — they cannot give legal advice or tell you what to do.
• Mediation communications are generally privileged under RCW 7.07.030, subject to statutory exceptions under RCW 7.07.050.
• If you reach an agreement, put it in writing. It does not become a court judgment unless the court enters it.
• If you want an agreement to be enforceable as a court judgment, ask the court to enter it as a stipulated judgment. RCW 12.40.100 addresses payment plans for judgments already entered by the court.

When Settlement Makes Sense

Settlement is worth considering when:

• The dispute is partially your fault and a trial could go either way
• The amount at stake doesn't justify the time and stress of a hearing
• You want to avoid a judgment on the civil docket (settlements can be structured as voluntary dismissals rather than judgments)
• You need a payment plan that a judge might not order

Settlement is less attractive when:

• The plaintiff's claim has no merit and you want it dismissed on the record
• You have a strong counterclaim worth more than the original claim
• The plaintiff is demanding the full amount with no room for compromise

The Washington Small Claims Response Guide includes a settlement and payment record tracker that walks you through documenting the agreement, filing written notice with the court, and confirming the dismissal went through.

See more Washington guides →