Ontario Small Claims Court Defendant Rights
You Have More Rights Than You Think
Being sued feels like being on the back foot. But defendants in Ontario's Small Claims Court have a clear set of procedural rights built into the Courts of Justice Act and the Small Claims Court Rules (O. Reg. 258/98). Knowing them helps you use them.
The Right to Respond
You have 20 calendar days from the date of service to serve and file a Defence (Form 9A). Within that window, you can dispute the entire claim, dispute part of it, or admit it and propose payment terms. If the plaintiff owes you money from the same dispute, you can also file a Defendant's Claim (Form 10A) within 20 days after filing your Defence; after that, the court may allow filing with leave before trial or default judgment.
Even if the 20-day window passes and you're noted in default, you still have the right to bring a motion (Form 15A) asking the court to set aside the default — provided you can show promptness, a reasonable explanation for the delay, and a viable defence on the merits.
The Right to Self-Representation
You don't need a lawyer or paralegal to defend yourself. Self-represented litigants have full standing in Small Claims Court — you can file documents, examine witnesses, present evidence, make arguments, and attend every step of the proceeding yourself.
If you do want help, you can retain a licensed lawyer or a licensed paralegal regulated by the Law Society of Ontario. Paralegals have full authority to represent clients in Small Claims Court (By-Law 4). You can also get help from:
- Pro Bono Ontario — free legal advice hotline (1-855-255-7256), up to 30 minutes
- Community Legal Education Ontario (CLEO) / Steps to Justice — free procedural guides and interactive pathways
- The Law Society Referral Service — a free 30-minute consultation with a lawyer or paralegal
Corporations have slightly different rules: under Rule 5.03, a corporation can be represented by a licensed lawyer, a licensed paralegal, or an authorized officer or employee with written authorization.
Free Download
Get the Ontario Small Claims Response Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
The Right to a Fair Hearing
Rule 1.03 states the court's mandate: to secure the just, most expeditious, and least expensive determination of every proceeding on its merits. That applies equally to plaintiffs and defendants.
At a settlement conference, the presiding deputy judge provides a neutral assessment and tries to facilitate resolution — but cannot force a settlement on either side. And under Rule 13.04, the settlement conference judge is barred from presiding at trial, so any opinions they express during settlement discussions don't carry over.
At trial, both sides present evidence and examine witnesses. The judge makes a decision based on the evidence, applying the balance of probabilities standard. The court can admit any oral testimony and document that is relevant, even if it wouldn't be admissible under stricter evidence rules in higher courts (Section 27, Courts of Justice Act).
Language and Accessibility
Under Section 125 of the Courts of Justice Act, you have the right to proceedings in English, French, or bilingually. If you need a court interpreter, submit a Request for Court Interpreter (Form FW-A-5) well before your hearing date.
Accessibility accommodations under the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act (AODA) are available through the courthouse's accessibility coordinator.
Costs Protection
Small Claims Court limits what the winning side can recover in costs. Under Section 29 of the Courts of Justice Act, assessable representation costs (excluding filing fees and disbursements) are generally capped at 15% of the amount claimed. On a $10,000 claim, that ordinary cap is $1,500, but exceptions can apply, including where an unrepresented party acted unreasonably or Rule 14 offer consequences apply.
Self-represented parties who made a reasonable settlement offer that was rejected and later succeed at trial can be awarded up to $1,500 for inconvenience and expense under Rule 19.05.
Formal Offers to Settle (Rule 14) carry their own costs consequences. If the plaintiff rejects your offer and then fails to beat it at trial, you may be entitled to costs from the date of the offer.
Fee Waivers
If you can't afford the $77 Defence filing fee, you can apply for a fee waiver under the Administration of Justice Act. You may qualify if your main household income is from Ontario Works (OW), ODSP, Old Age Security with the Guaranteed Income Supplement, the War Veterans Allowance, or Canada Pension Plan benefits; if your lawyer is paid by a Legal Aid Certificate; or if you meet the household income thresholds and have household liquid assets below $2,800 and net worth below $11,100. For a single-person household, the gross annual income threshold is $33,100.
Submit Fee Waiver Request (Form FW-A-3) to the court clerk, or Form FW-A-4 for a judge's review if you don't meet the standard criteria but face extreme financial hardship.
Appeal Rights
If the final order goes against you and the amount in dispute exceeds $5,000, exclusive of costs, you can appeal to the Divisional Court within 30 days after the order. Claims of $5,000 or less are final and cannot be appealed.
One limitation: licensed paralegals can represent you in Small Claims Court but not in Divisional Court. If you're appealing, you'll need a lawyer or must proceed as a self-represented litigant.
The Ontario Small Claims Court Defence Guide covers each of these rights with practical checklists — from fee waiver applications to settlement offer strategy and appeal deadlines.
Get Your Free Ontario Small Claims Response Checklist
Download the Ontario Small Claims Response Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.