How to Prepare Evidence for NWT Small Claims Court Hearing

Evidence Comes Before Arguments

Most self-represented claimants in the Territorial Court of the Northwest Territories spend their preparation time rehearsing what they want to say. The judge cares far more about what you can prove. A well-organized evidence package — contracts, invoices, photographs, text messages, receipts — does the heavy lifting. Your oral testimony fills the gaps.

Under the Civil Claims Rules, evidence exchange happens after mandatory mediation fails and before the trial date. The mediation judge sets specific deadlines for serving copies of documents on the other side and filing them with the court. Miss those deadlines and the judge may refuse to admit your exhibits.

Gathering Your Documents

Start with the paper trail that proves your claim existed before the dispute:

• Contracts and written agreements — even informal ones (emails confirming a price, text messages accepting terms)
• Invoices, receipts, and proof of payment — bank statements showing transfers, cancelled cheques, e-transfer confirmations
• Photographs — dated photos of property damage, defective goods, incomplete work. Metadata from your phone camera helps establish when the photo was taken
• Repair estimates or quotes — at least two independent quotes for property damage or defective work claims
• Correspondence — demand letters you sent, the defendant's responses (or non-responses), any written admissions

Organize these chronologically. Number each document as an exhibit (Exhibit A, Exhibit B, and so on) and prepare a copy for yourself, each opposing party, and the court as directed by the mediation judge.

Text Messages and Electronic Evidence

Text messages, WhatsApp conversations, and emails can be useful evidence in the Territorial Court. Print them out — screenshots can help show the sender, recipient, date, and conversation thread. The judge decides whether to admit them and what weight to give them. If the messages are long, highlight the specific passages that support your claim.

If you have audio or video recordings, the judge may require a written transcript. Bring the recording on accessible media (a phone or USB drive) and have the transcript ready in case the judge asks for it.

Calling Witnesses

If someone saw the events that led to your claim — a neighbour who witnessed property damage, a colleague who overheard an agreement — they can testify at trial. Voluntary witnesses simply show up on the hearing date.

If a witness will not come voluntarily, you can compel their attendance with Form 16 (Notice to Attend). The filing fee is $25, and you must serve the notice on the witness along with statutory conduct money for travel expenses. This applies to witnesses who hold records too — a bank employee who can confirm a bounced cheque, for example.

What Happens at the Hearing

The trial follows a set sequence:

1. Check-in — arrive 15 minutes early and confirm your attendance with the court clerk
2. Preliminary directions — the judge addresses any procedural issues, confirms exhibit lists, and may exclude witnesses from the courtroom until they testify
3. Your case — as the claimant, you go first. Present an opening statement (keep it brief), give evidence under oath, introduce your exhibits one at a time, and call your witnesses. The defendant cross-examines each witness
4. Defendant's case — the defendant presents their evidence, calls witnesses, and you cross-examine
5. Closing submissions — short arguments summarizing what the evidence proved. The claimant goes first, the defendant responds

The judge may deliver an oral decision at the end of the hearing or reserve judgment and mail a written decision later. The ruling becomes a Payment Order (Form 21) specifying the amount awarded, costs, and pre-judgment interest.

Preparing for Cross-Examination

When the other side or their representative asks you questions under oath, stay factual. Answer the question that was asked — do not volunteer extra information. If you do not know something, say so. The judge notices when witnesses speculate instead of sticking to what they observed.

Prepare the same way for cross-examining the other side's witnesses. Write out your questions in advance, focusing on contradictions between their testimony and the documents in evidence.

Remote Community Considerations

If your hearing is scheduled during a circuit sitting in a community like Fort Smith, Fort Simpson, Norman Wells, or Tuktoyaktuk, confirm the date with the court registry in advance. Circuit sittings happen periodically and can shift. Bring all your exhibits in physical form — do not rely on email or digital-only copies in communities where courtroom technology may be limited.

If you cannot attend in person, you can apply to appear by telephone or video using Form 40 (Application to Judge). File this well before the hearing date.

The Complete Preparation Toolkit

The NWT Small Claims Filing Guide includes a mediation preparation worksheet, a service tracker, and step-by-step instructions for every stage from filing Form 1 through to enforcing a judgment. If mandatory mediation did not resolve your dispute and you are heading to trial, the guide walks through what the judge expects at each stage.

See more Northwest Territories guides →