Landlord or Tenant Sued at the NZ Disputes Tribunal — Which Forum Handles Your Case?

When Does the Disputes Tribunal Handle Landlord–Tenant Cases?

Most landlord–tenant disputes in New Zealand go to the Tenancy Tribunal under the Residential Tenancies Act 1986 — bond refunds, rent arrears, maintenance obligations, and notice periods all fall squarely in that forum. But the Disputes Tribunal still handles a specific slice of property-related claims between landlords and tenants.

The Disputes Tribunal has jurisdiction when a claim falls outside the Residential Tenancies Act. Claims arising from a residential tenancy agreement belong in the Tenancy Tribunal, including after the tenancy ends. Separate civil claims that do not arise from the tenancy may fall within the Disputes Tribunal. Examples include:

• Separate property damage claims — for example, a landlord's contractor damages a tenant's personal belongings in circumstances unrelated to tenancy obligations
• Contractual disputes unrelated to the tenancy agreement — a side agreement for gardening services, storage fees, or renovation contributions
• Flatmate disputes (not covered by the RTA) involving shared household costs, personal property, or unpaid bill shares

If your dispute arises from a residential tenancy agreement — such as a bond, rent, maintenance, or damage claim — the Tenancy Tribunal has exclusive jurisdiction under the RTA. A separate claim does not fall there solely because the parties are a landlord and tenant. Filing in the wrong forum wastes time and fees — the Disputes Tribunal referee will decline jurisdiction and direct you across.

Responding as a Landlord Sued by a Former Tenant

A former tenant might bring a Disputes Tribunal claim over unreturned personal property, belongings damaged by a landlord's contractor in circumstances unrelated to tenancy obligations, or a side agreement outside the formal tenancy. Your Notice of Hearing arrives with a CIV reference number from the Ministry of Justice.

Start by confirming the claim genuinely belongs in the Disputes Tribunal — if the tenant's complaint actually relates to bond, maintenance, or tenancy conditions, you can raise a jurisdictional objection at the hearing. Gather your evidence: the tenancy agreement (to show what's covered by the RTA and what isn't), any separate contracts, photographs, and communication records.

If you believe the tenant owes you money under a separate agreement unrelated to tenancy obligations, you can file a counterclaim using the standard claim form and referencing the existing CIV number.

Responding as a Tenant Sued by a Former Landlord

If a former landlord sues you in the Disputes Tribunal, check whether the claim arises from the residential tenancy agreement. Claims about tenancy-related damage remain within the Tenancy Tribunal's jurisdiction even if the bond did not cover the loss; a distinct claim outside the RTA may fall in the Disputes Tribunal.

Prepare your evidence chronologically: move-in photos, condition reports, the bond outcome from the Tenancy Tribunal (if any), and all communications. The bond outcome is relevant evidence if the landlord claims for the same damage; also raise the forum issue if the claim arises from the tenancy.

Practical Steps for Either Side

1. Verify your Notice of Hearing — call 0800 COURTS (0800 268 787) and quote your CIV number
2. Check jurisdiction — does the claim relate to a tenancy agreement? If yes, it likely belongs in the Tenancy Tribunal
3. Gather evidence — photographs, contracts, the tenancy agreement, bond resolution documents, and any communication records
4. Consider a counterclaim — file it as soon as possible using the standard claim form with your CIV reference
5. Attend the hearing — the referee can proceed without you and issue an order based solely on the other side's evidence

The NZ Disputes Tribunal Response Guide walks through each of these steps with worksheets for evidence organisation, a notice verification checklist, and a counterclaim preparation walkthrough — built specifically for respondents navigating an unfamiliar process.

Getting Help

Community Law Centres provide free legal information and can help you understand whether your dispute belongs in the Disputes Tribunal or Tenancy Tribunal. Citizens Advice Bureau volunteers can also assist with basic guidance. Neither can represent you at the hearing — lawyers are barred from appearing in the Disputes Tribunal — but getting the forum question right early saves weeks of wasted effort.

See more New Zealand guides →