How to Respond to Small Claims Court in Kentucky

First: Verify the Papers Are Real

When you receive a certified mail envelope or personal delivery from a sheriff's deputy, the package should contain two things — a civil summons and a copy of Form AOC-175 (the Small Claims Complaint). The summons tells you the hearing date, time, and courtroom. The AOC-175 tells you who is suing you, how much they want, and the basic facts of their claim.

Before doing anything else, confirm the case exists. Call the Circuit Court Clerk's office in the county listed on the papers using the phone number from kycourts.gov — not from the papers themselves. You can also search the case number on CourtNet 2.0, though newly filed cases sometimes take several days to appear online.

Keep every piece of the mailing — the envelope, the green certified mail receipt, the summons, the complaint. Do not write on them or throw any of it away.

You Do Not Need to File a Written Answer

This is the single most important thing to understand. In Kentucky small claims court, there is no written answer requirement. No form to file. No 20-day deadline. The confusion comes from standard civil court rules (CR 12.01), which require a written answer in regular District or Circuit Court cases. Those rules do not apply in the small claims division.

Your response to the lawsuit is showing up at the hearing. Physical appearance at the scheduled date and time serves as a complete denial of the plaintiff's claims and preserves every defense you have.

If you have seen online advice about filing a written "Answer" to avoid default, that advice almost certainly applies to debt collection lawsuits in regular civil court, not to small claims. Kentucky small claims and debt collection cases follow different procedures.

Your Four Options as a Defendant

Once you have confirmed the case is legitimate, you have four paths:

1. Dispute the claim at the hearing. Show up, present your evidence, and let the judge decide. You do not need to file anything before the hearing to contest the case. Prepare your documents, bring copies, and be ready to explain your side.

2. Settle before the hearing. Contact the plaintiff (or their attorney) and negotiate a resolution. If you reach an agreement, put it in writing on Form AOC-199 (Small Claims Settlement Agreement) and submit it to the judge, who signs Form AOC-199.1 to make it official. A verbal agreement does not by itself close the case or cancel the hearing.

3. File a counterclaim. If the plaintiff actually owes you money from the same transaction — for example, a contractor who damaged your property while doing the work they are billing you for — file Form AOC-185 with the Circuit Court Clerk at least five days before the hearing. Serve a copy on the plaintiff. The counterclaim amount cannot exceed $2,500. Under KRS 24A.310(1), a compulsory counterclaim over that limit transfers the case out of small claims.

4. Admit and pay. If the claim is valid and you owe the money, you can pay the plaintiff directly. But payment alone does not close a pending case. Before judgment, formalize a settlement with Form AOC-199 and submit it to the judge for entry of Form AOC-199.1. If a judgment has already been entered and paid, use Form AOC-191 (Motion for Satisfaction of Judgment) to request that it be cleared from the record.

Key Deadlines to Track

• Hearing date: On the summons. Miss it and the judge enters a default judgment against you.
• Counterclaim filing: At least 5 days before the hearing (not counting the hearing day itself).
• Jury trial demand: At least 7 days before the hearing, in writing to the clerk. Available when the plaintiff's claim or the value of property in dispute exceeds $250. Transfers the case to regular District Court.
• Appeal: 10 calendar days after the judgment is entered, if you lose.

For the counterclaim and jury-demand deadlines measured backward from the hearing, a calculated deadline falling on a weekend or legal holiday rolls back to the preceding business day.

Debt Collection Cases Are Different

If the plaintiff is a credit card company, debt buyer, or collection agency, the case falls under consumer debt collection rules with different protections. The guide and procedures described here apply to non-debt small claims — contractor disputes, landlord-tenant issues, service disagreements, vehicle sales. If you have been sued by a creditor or collector, contact a legal aid organization immediately.

The Kentucky Small Claims Response Guide covers the full defendant process from the moment you are served through the hearing and beyond, including deadline tracking worksheets and an evidence organization binder.

See more Kentucky guides →