What Happens at a Disputes Tribunal Hearing in New Zealand

Walking into a Disputes Tribunal hearing without knowing how it works is the most common source of anxiety for first-time applicants. The good news: it's nothing like what you've seen on courtroom TV shows. There's no judge in robes, no cross-examination by lawyers, and no jury. But there is a structure, and understanding it gives you a real advantage.

How the Hearing Works

Disputes Tribunal hearings are private. They take place in a closed room — no public gallery, no media. The session is presided over by a Referee (not a judge), and the approach is inquisitorial rather than adversarial. That means the Referee actively guides the discussion, asks questions, and examines evidence rather than sitting silently while each side presents.

Here's the typical sequence:

1. Introduction. The Referee explains the ground rules, confirms both parties' identities, and outlines how the session will run.

2. Applicant's statement. You explain what happened, what you're claiming, and why. Stick to facts and chronology — the Referee doesn't need your emotions, they need your evidence.

3. Respondent's statement. The other party gives their version. The Referee may ask them questions based on what you said.

4. Discussion and questioning. The Referee may go back and forth between parties, ask for clarification, and examine physical evidence. They might also suggest a settlement if both sides seem close to an agreement.

5. Decision. If a settlement isn't reached, the Referee makes a binding decision. Sometimes this is announced at the hearing; sometimes the written order arrives by post within a few weeks.

What to Bring

Your evidence bundle is the single most important thing you bring. The Registry and the respondent should already have a copy (submitted at least five working days before the hearing), but bring your own organised set as well.

A solid evidence bundle includes:

• A one-page summary — your claim in a few paragraphs, with the specific dollar amount and what you're asking the Referee to order
• A chronological table — dates of the transaction, the problem, your attempts to resolve it, and your demand letter
• Contracts, invoices, or quotes — the original agreement, any written quotes, purchase orders
• Photos — clear, printed colour photos of defective work, damaged goods, or relevant property
• Correspondence — printed email threads, text message screenshots (with dates visible), your demand letter and proof of delivery
• Financial documents — bank statements, repair quotes, or receipts showing your actual loss

Number your pages and reference them in your summary. "As shown on page 7 of my evidence bundle" is far more effective than waving a loose stack of papers at the Referee.

What If the Other Party Doesn't Show Up?

If the respondent was properly served but doesn't attend, the Referee can proceed in their absence under Section 19(1)(i) of the Disputes Tribunal Act 1988. But this isn't an automatic win — you still need to present enough evidence to satisfy the Referee that your claim is valid and your calculation is correct.

The Referee can also choose to adjourn the hearing to give the respondent another chance to attend, or to strike out the proceedings entirely.

Settlement at the Hearing

The Referee's primary duty under Section 18 is to facilitate a fair settlement. Many hearings end in an agreed resolution rather than an imposed order. If you reach a settlement, ask that it be recorded as a formal consent order — this makes it legally enforceable through the District Court if the other party later reneges.

A handshake agreement that isn't recorded as a consent order is not a Tribunal order, so it cannot be enforced through the Tribunal's order-enforcement process.

Practical Tips

Arrive early. Give yourself time to find the room and settle your nerves.

Dress normally. This isn't the High Court. Clean, tidy clothes are fine — you don't need a suit.

Address the Referee directly. Speak to the Referee, not to the other party. If you have a point to make about something the respondent said, direct it through the Referee.

Don't interrupt. You'll get your turn. Interrupting makes a poor impression on the person who's about to decide your case.

Bring a support person if you want one. Under Section 38(6), you can bring a family member or friend for moral support. They can sit with you but cannot speak on your behalf or address the Tribunal.

Request an interpreter in advance. If you need to give evidence in Te Reo Māori or NZSL, the Registry provides interpreters free of charge — but you must request one at least ten working days before the hearing.

The step-by-step Disputes Tribunal guide includes a hearing-day summary sheet for structuring your opening statement and a full evidence preparation worksheet.

See more New Zealand guides →