Alaska Small Claims Court: Witness and Exhibit Rules

Evidence at an Informal Hearing

Alaska small claims hearings operate under relaxed evidence rules. The formal Rules of Evidence don't apply — the judge or magistrate can consider any relevant, credible evidence that helps resolve the dispute, including hearsay, narrative testimony, text message screenshots, and photographs. But "informal" doesn't mean "unstructured." The judge still expects organized, legible evidence presented in a way that's easy to follow.

The difference between winning and losing often comes down to preparation, not legal arguments. A defendant with a neatly organized evidence binder and clear testimony makes a stronger impression than someone fumbling through a stack of loose papers.

Preparing Your Exhibits

Organize by chronology or topic. If your dispute is about a construction project, arrange your evidence in the order things happened: the contract, then change orders, then photos of defective work, then repair estimates, then payment records. If it's a landlord-tenant deposit dispute, start with the lease, then move-in photos, then move-out photos, then the itemized deduction list (or lack of one).

Number every page. Sequential pagination lets you reference specific documents during testimony — "Your Honor, please look at page 7, which shows the text message where the plaintiff acknowledged the work was incomplete." The judge is reviewing evidence from both sides simultaneously; page numbers keep everyone oriented.

Bring three copies. One for the judge, one for the opposing party, and one for yourself. The judge's copy stays with the court. The opposing party's copy is their right — they need to see what you're presenting.

Use originals when possible. The judge may accept photocopies, but bring originals to the hearing in case the judge wants to inspect them. This matters particularly for contracts with signatures, photographs where detail matters, and any document the other party might claim is altered.

Types of Evidence That Work

Written documents — contracts, invoices, receipts, repair estimates, bank statements, payment confirmations. These are the backbone of most small claims cases.

Photographs and videos — timestamped photos of property damage, construction defects, the condition of a rental unit at move-in and move-out, a vehicle's condition at the time of sale. Print photographs large enough for the judge to see details.

Text messages and emails — screenshots showing agreements, admissions, demands, or refusals. Include enough context that each message makes sense on its own — a single text pulled out of a 200-message thread can be misleading.

Written estimates — quotes from licensed professionals (mechanics, contractors, appraisers) that establish the cost of repairs or the value of damaged property.

Calling Witnesses

If someone has relevant firsthand knowledge — they saw the condition of the property, witnessed the handshake deal, or performed the repair estimate — their testimony can strengthen your case. Witnesses testify under oath, and the judge will ask them questions directly.

Voluntary witnesses just need to show up at the right time and place. Give them the hearing date, time, and courtroom location well in advance.

If a witness refuses to attend, you can compel their testimony with a subpoena. The forms are:

• Form CIV-111 — Subpoena to Appear (testimony only)
• Form CIV-110 — Subpoena to Appear and Produce (testimony plus documents)

You must serve the subpoena on the witness and include the required witness fees:

• $12.50 if their total attendance and travel time is 3 hours or less
• $25.00 if attendance and travel exceeds 3 hours
• Round-trip mileage reimbursement if the witness travels more than 30 miles from their residence, at the state employee reimbursement rate

Pre-Filing Your Evidence

Under the District Court rules, you should file your exhibits with the court clerk and serve copies on the opposing party before the hearing date. This gives the judge time to review the materials and prevents surprises at the hearing.

For defendants appearing telephonically under Form SC-31, pre-filing evidence is essential — you can't hand documents to the judge over the phone. Mail your evidence binder to the clerk well in advance and keep an identical copy for reference during the hearing.

What the Judge Does With Your Evidence

The judge reviews all evidence from both sides, asks clarifying questions, and may actively direct the questioning. Cross-examination is permitted — the other party can ask your witnesses questions, and you can question theirs.

After hearing everything, the judge issues a written judgment. If you disagree with the outcome, you can appeal to the Superior Court within 30 days after notice of entry of judgment.

For step-by-step guidance on building your evidence package and preparing for the hearing, the Responding to a Small Claims Case in Alaska guide includes an exhibit organizer and a hearing preparation checklist.

See more Alaska guides →